Medium Format Filing Systems
by Robert Monaghan

Local Related Links:
Archival Storage Pages
Medium Format Slide Projector Pages

How can you store your medium format negatives and slides?

Simplest Storage System

The simplest and lowest cost storage system is simply to use whatever your commercial processor uses to send back images to you. Oftentimes, you will get negatives and slides returned in protective clear plastic sleeves, sometimes in crush resistant (yellow) boxes.

The obvious problem with this system is finding anything when you want it.

A first step is to label the processed rolls by date, film type, format, and general subject matter. The date helps you split different trips to the same destination, for example. Film type is critical on deciding whether you need an enlarger or slide projector, among other obvious needs. If you shoot multiple formats such as 35mm and 6x6cm, you will want a quick way to tell them apart. General subject matter is obviously subjective.

See film page for film related types, formats, and related resources.

The next steps require you to think about what your photographic goals are. What do you want to do with your photographs?

If you are operating a business, you may have other needs besides simple storage. You may need to quickly find a portrait photograph from a high school graduation shoot to make profitable copies for grandparents. You may have to find that model release to sell a stock photograph to a medical supply house for a catalog.

Avoiding Databases

As a computer science grad, I have had to create and implement far too many databases. The key to effective database use is to put in the data that you will need to find what you need - and nothing more!

You can find many databases which make it possible to link a scanned thumbnail image to various data. Unfortunately, we don't have a more effective way to link the content of an image to a computer scannable text format - so far.

Many amateur photographers think they should carefully record f-stops and lens type, film speed, and so on for their photographs. So far as I know, absolutely none of the pros in photography actually do such time-wasting busy-work. It's all made up bulls*it. A few pros like Roger Hicks and Frances Shultze (see their great Film Book) come out and admit it. I find very few times when I need to record such data myself, except for lens testing and macro-photography flash settings tests.

Hanging Slide Page Approach

You can purchase a compact and very handy photographic file folder cabinet for hanging file style photo pages for negatives or slides. These pages can easily be labeled and numbered to keep them organized. It is relatively easy to pull one of these pages and pop it on a light table for a close look using a loupe.

See Homebrew Loupe Options for more information on some medium format and 35mm loupes you can build inexpensively.

You can also buy an oversize notebook to hold slide pages, with enough slack to permit putting a thin light-table with fluorescent light under each page for a quick look.

I like a simple alternative to this high priced photo-gadget approach. I simply have my photography project file pages of slides in marked file folder boxes with matching top and bottom sections. I open the box, put the top on the other end of the light table. Now I just grab the slide pages, slip them across the light table for a look, then flip over and down into the box top. When done, I just reset the pages back into the box bottom. Simple. Cheap. Fast. Really cheap. Easy.

At the higher end, you can have very fancy light table setups aimed at art directors and others who have the need for maximum convenience, regardless of the hefty price. Angled like drafting tables, they can examine hundreds of slide pages in total comfort - at a high price!

The most critical point about the filing cabinet approach not pointed out above is that these systems are often potentially fireproof. Given what you probably have invested in your slides and negatives, this is a non-trivial benefit. You probably can't insure your slides and negative images for their value as stock photographs and so on.

See photography insurance pages for more policy related information.

Personally, as a certified disaster recovery planner, I have seen too many photographs of burnt out and destroyed facilities where even a "fire-proof" safe would have melted down or burned the slides and negatives in it. The only really sure protection is an off-site copy of your most precious slides (family etc.). See section on duplicating below.

Culling Triage

I feel pretty happy to get a good shot or two out of a roll of 35mm film or a roll of 120 film. The process of finding that good shot is called culling.

Culling triage is the process of separating the great shot(s) from the bad shots, with the average shots inbetween.

If you are getting more than one or two great slides per roll, you probably aren't shooting enough film!

I'm serious. A major difference between the professional and amateur is that the professional usually shoots more film. They know that the averages will be with them if they shoot a lot of film. A sports photography pro might shoot 20, 30, or even more rolls of film during a game, just to be sure of getting that key photograph. Other pros will carefully bracket their shots, often at third-stop or half-stop intervals over a wide range. Film is cheap - relative to the opportunity cost to shoot it!

Great versus Average Shots

You just have to look at a lot of photographs by master photographers to get a feel for great photography. Reviewing photographs in various high quality photography magazines and other publications and books is also a way to develop a feel for great photographs. Having another pro or serious amateur review your photographs can also be helpful. But ultimately, as a serious amateur photographer, you have to set your own standards for what you like and want. Neither I nor anyone else can set your standards for you!

The great photographs are the ones you want to have duplicated for your slide shows, or laser scanned and printed, or carefully printed and mounted. It is helpful and important to your development as a photographer to have your own photographs in your environment - it is great feedback!

Average Shots

Your average shots might be better than somebody else's best shots. But you have to make this triage work, or be inundated with slides and negatives and prints.

I have a lot of on-going photography projects. Some projects related to abstract patterns, color, reflections in buildings, found still-lifes, landscape shots, travel photographs, technical photography (astrophotography, underwater critter portraits, microphotography) and so on.

Sandwich Shots

What's a sandwich shot? Sandwich shots are made with the intent of using them in a multi-image sandwich of film or its slide duplicator equivalent. Usually these shots are not great shots, until you combine them with something else.

For example, I shoot some moon shots using long lenses (up to 2400mm) and guided telescopes. I have shots of the moon in each corner, in the center, and so on. Now suppose I want to put a nice full moon into a city at night landscape where there wasn't any moon that night? Easy, right? I just use a slide duplicator and make the proper exposure to get the desired sandwich shot.

The same approach works to put dramatic skies and clouds into your dull white overcast travel slides. Want a flock of birds in the right place? How big? How many birds? Going East or West? With a selection of sandwich shots, you can jazz up many average shots into eye-openers.

With Photoshop and similar image manipulating programs, you may have a lot of buried gold in your average shots. I suggest this is one reason for keeping them rather than trashing them as many folks do.

Bad Shots May Teach You More Than You Might Think

Many folks simply throw away their bad slides right out of the box. I used to teach beginning and advanced underwater photography, so I also collected representative bad shots for teaching purposes.

I started to track my bad shots, in order to find why they were bad. Unless you do this, you may not improve as quickly as you can or should. I found out I was over-estimating the distance my underwater strobe could cover adequately on many shots. I got a more powerful strobe, and soon found I had much fewer such too dark shots.

I also found I wasn't advancing my 35mm film enough to get past the light-struck portion on my Nikonos I/II cameras. But I had to look at a pile of bad first shot slides ruined this way before I applied the obvious cure. Now I advance a bit more and often use that first shot as an information and grey card frame.

This same problem recording and analysis approach should be applied to your bad slide pile. Try to figure out why you have so many bad slides or negatives. What can you do to fix or avoid these problems?

At the same time, photography is a bit like cancer surgery. You should expect to get a certain number of bad shots, and not expect every shot to result in a "keeper".

Bracketed shots are a version of planned bad slides, using film as cheap insurance to ensure getting the ideal shot. The various under-exposed and over-exposed slides may be technically bad, or simply range around the best exposure shot.

There is a certain amount of opinion here, so it is best not to discard the "close" brackets. That art director might prefer over-exposed pastel colors, while I like deeper saturated colors. If you have the bracketed shots, you can pull them out and make the art director happy too.

I also want to make the observation that you should consider experimenting with the last few frames in your camera, depending on your style of photography. I will often shoot some patterns or reflections in building windows shots to clear out a roll of film. Most of your experiments may be failures as great photographs, but they may be a good test of what your lens can do or whatever.

Similarly, lens testing rolls are almost never great photographs (although I often shoot some real world shots and macro shots that might work out!). These shots should be carefully labeled and stored. You can check out changes in lens performance by reference to these lens testing slides. If a lens is dropped or abused, I would highly recommend this test.

See Camera and Lens Testing Pages for lens testing tips.

The average shots category should be the majority of your slides or negatives.

Format Issues

The problem is more complex if you have multiple medium format resources, including 4x4cm superslides, 6x4.5cm, 6x6, 6x7, 6x8, 6x9, 6x12, and 6x17 format options.

The format problem is somewhat less of a problem than it might seem at first. If you are using 120 film width slide or negative pages, you can often fit various lengths and formats of film into the standard pages. Actually, your processor will probably cut the film into lengths that fit their mailers and standard length pages.

Be sure to alert your processor if you are using any odd non-standard formats (especially the longer panoramics).

Be sure to alert them if you are using mixed formats. Some cameras let you switch from one format to another film length in the middle of a roll. Be sure to warn your processor to watch out for such transitions, and to not cut the film in the middle of a shot!

If you change film in mid-roll, be sure to alert the processor again! Here again, you run the risk that they will start the mounting process. Everything is fine, until they hit the mid-roll change. Now they are out of synch with the images on film, and may slice up some of your shots.

What if you have an older medium format camera, one which has framing errors (such as Kiev 88, older Koni-omegas, Bronicas, and so on). Here again, you really need to be alert to these problems.

It is also worthwhile to ask for at least one test roll to be developed unmounted, and returned to you in sleeves. You may be shocked to find that the mechanics have become worn, and you are in danger of getting overlapped and ruined shots in the near future. You can also see if your camera has irregular film spacing, as often happens in older (and some newer) medium format cameras as they wear.

See Camera and Lens Testing Tips pages for more related framing error testing tips.

If you are doing night shots, I highly recommend that you shoot at least the first shot on the roll using flash. A grey card is very handy for curing some color-shifts in reciprocity effects. You can record roll number and date and other information on a 3x5 card on the center of the grey card (using poster-mounting silicon rubber "tacky" stuff). Unless you do this, the processor may not be able to properly align the remaining shots. You risk having them cut some of your night shots in the middle of the film due to the lack of clear frame dividers in night shots.

See Reciprocity Pages for details on film reciprocity.

Unmounted Slides

Slides can be returned unmounted, usually also in protective clear plastic sleeves. This unmounted slides in sleeves approach is also often less costly than having your slides individually mounted in cardboard mounts.

It is important that you make sure that the sleeving material used to store your slides are archival quality material. Non-archival quality slide pages and storage pages may have chemicals and fumes which can vaporize out and onto your slides over time. The effects on your slides are potentially a disaster over enough time.

See archival storage tips pages for more information on archival issues and resources.

Frankly, most cardboard slides used by processors are not the sturdiest and best slide mounts available, but usually more like the cheapest! You will often want or have to unmount your cardboard slides in order to remount them in a higher quality mount.

Be careful in considering whether you want to subject your original slides to lengthy projection sessions. All slides have colors which fade with projection. The brighter the light, and the longer the projection, the more the degradation. The main solution here is to avoid projecting your valued originals. Make a copy, and project the copies on your shows.

This advice is especially easy to do if you use superslides for your shows. Superslides are circa 4x4cm square slides that fit into most standard 35mm slide projectors (in special 2x2 inch square superslide mounts). A superslide has roughly double the film area of a 35mm slide, and at least double the impact. In addition, the original square format of 6x6cm slides can be preserved on superslides.

For more on superslides, see Superslides Pages.

Duplicates

If you prefer, you can shoot slide duplicates of your originals using various closeup setups. Alternatively, many processors have slide duplication options for standard formats. For non-standard formats, you may be on your own. Some folks use a contact printing style setup, only exposing the odd-format film directly onto the copying film.

Shooting duplicates may be another reason for using unmounted slides and negatives. The standard cardboard holders used by many processors may cover up the edges of the image, part of the design to minimize framing and cutting errors. Be aware that many supposedly 1:1 duplicators don't actually go to a true 1:1 ratio. The duplicated slides end up with a ring or border not on the original slide. This problem is easiest to solve by switching to a bellows format duplicator.

Seconds

Frankly, it is much cheaper to shoot seconds instead of duplicates. Simply shoot a second shot of that nice sunset or landscape or other great photographic scene.

Now you have a second copy of the image, which is actually an original image identical in contrast and processing and so on to the original shot.

One of the best part of a second shot is that it is much cheaper than a duplicated slide at the processor, while being technically better (in color fidelity and contrast).

A second hidden feature of shooting a second is that it is a protection against certain processing and film cutting errors that might destroy your original first shot.

Some medium format users have the option of using second backs on their Bronicas, Hasselblads, Rolleis, and so on. One approach to shooting seconds is to shoot the second shot on an identical film type and format in a second back.

Now if you are really paranoid (ahem!), you arrange to have this second film processed at a different time and batch than the first. You may wait until you get the first one back before processing the second, if time permits. If you are really, really paranoid, you have it processed by a different processor! Murphy's Law works overtime on ruining your best shots, so paranoia may be justified!


Related Postings

rec.photo.misc
From: Alan F Cross AlanX@proaxis.demon.co.uk
[1] Re: Looking for a database program
Date: Mon Feb 08 1999

Gil Stamper gstamper@us.hsanet.net writes

>I'm looking for a database program to help me catalog my slides.  I'm
>looking for something specifically written for slides, so that it will
>ask all the questions concerning camera and exposure information, model
>name, location, etc.  I could, I know, get a database program and "roll
>my own", but I feel sure that there is already something out there.  So
>I'm asking for pointers.
>
>All help appreciated.  If this is the wrong NG, please point me to the
>correct one.
>
>Gil
>gstamper@us.hsanet.net

Strongly recommend you take a look at PhotoTracker...

http://members.aol.com/PhotoNews

I'm a satisfied user, no connection with Robert Walchli, who designed the product around the FileMaker runtime product (so it has the power of FileMaker without needing FileMaker installed).

--
Alan Cross
Wokingham, Berkshire, UK.
email alias: ACross@iee.org
See me at www.proaxis.demon.co.uk


rec.photo.misc
From: cmarsh76@hotmail.com
[1] Re: Looking for a database program
Date: Mon Feb 08 1999

Microsoft Access 97 has a pretty detailed "Picture Library" database template that includes location, exposure info etc. You can make it as detailed as you need and create your own fields.

Chris


Date: Tue, 26 Jan 1999
From: "John H. Beverly" olhenry@shell.iag.net
Subject: Re: [KOML] Storing Negatives

Diane Sample wrote:

> I am new to the world of Medium Format, having recently acquired a Rapid
> Omega 100 with 90mm, 135mm and 180mm lenses, several 120 and 220 backs
> and a great flash.  So far the quality of the photos seems to be
> excellent, and I am thrilled with what I've got.
>
> My question is this.  What have you found to be the best way to store
> and label these 6x7 roll negatives?!?  I'm sure there are many different
> systems, so I'd be interested in any suggestions.
>
> Thanks in advance.
>
> Diane

Sounds like you have aquired some nice equipment. I've never tried to store uncut rolls of film as a roll. Usually, I cut the film and store the cut negs in glasines which are available from American Envolope and Paper Co. and at most camera stores at a much greater cost, also, check with a pro lab where your film is process, they generally have glasines available to their customers.




End of Page