Wednesday 04 February 2009 | China feed | All feeds

Advertisement

You are here:

  1. Home
  2. News
  3. World News
  4. Asia
  5. China

China's Dongtan demise is mirrored by bad news for Britain's eco-towns

The failure of Dongtan, which has been praised by Gordon Brown as a vision of the future, raises questions about Britain's plans for similar eco-towns.

 

The Prime Minister announced during a visit to Shanghai in January that the Chinese project would serve as a model for up to 10 eco-towns that are scheduled to be built in Britain by 2020.

Such towns are a pet project for Mr Brown, and part of a strategy to show that Labour's commitment to the environment can match David Cameron's enthusiasm for all things green.

The involvement of a British company, Arup, in a Chinese landmark project has been heavily promoted by Mr Brown. "I want to mention the higher level of cooperation that is now existing on one of the greatest issues that faces the world, the environment," Mr Brown told an audience in Shanghai in January.

"We now enter a new era of cooperation that extends beyond the economy, a new era of environmental cooperation," he added.

The prime minister pledged to twin Dongtan with the Thames Gateway project, another Arup scheme to create "Britain's first eco-region".

He announced that Britain would give China £50 million from Britain's "Environmental Transformation Fund" to "support investment in energy efficiency and in renewables", and announced the creation of a "virtual sustainable cities academy" where researchers in the two countries could pool their ideas and information.

Notably, however, Mr Brown did not actually visit the site of Dongtan, despite Chongming Island lying only 45 minutes away by boat. A succession of other British politicians, including Tony Blair, John Prescott and Ken Livingstone, have all praised the "city" without ever setting foot on its site.

Meanwhile in Britain, plans to build such eco-towns have met strong opposition from the surrounding areas, with residents objecting that they are a flimsy excuse for building on greenfield sites and will choke the countryside with traffic. Campaigners have also been granted a judicial review of the government plans.

Ministers unveiled a shortlist of 15 possible sites in April which are set to be whittled down to "up to 10" next year.

Mr Brown promised in Shanghai that there would be "far better systems of transport, hydrogen-fuelled cars rather than cars fuelled by ordinary petrol, a whole range of systems for dealing with clean water and for the supply of energy. That is what eco-cities and eco-towns will offer in both Britain and China."

Advertisement
Advertisement

EDITOR'S CHOICE

Australian Aboriginal art

Aboriginal artist Bessie Nakamarra Sims

Bessie is a rising star in Australia's £150m Aboriginal art industry but she is not rich. Will Storr discovers why.

NEWS MOST VIEWED

Sponsored Features

Australia's Northern Territory

Hugh Jackman says the real star of his new film Australia is the landscape. Discover the Northern Territory here.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

Pictures of the day

Nappies for birds

Today: nappies for birds, circus of horrors and tampon Mona Lisa.

Celebrity sightings

Our regularly-updated review of celebrity photos and paparazzi snaps.

Readers' pictures IV

More photos of snowballs, snowmen, snowdogs, snowcats and snowfights.

Sponsored Features

40 free prints with Photobox

New customers registering today will receive 40 prints for free. Order now.

50 free music downloads

We've teamed up with eMusic to offer Telegraph readers the latest music downloads.

James Bartholomew - 2009: The year of capital destruction

Stock market stinkers

'I did my research and bought the shares. A week later they halved.'

The world's weirdest hotels

Weird hotels: part two

Another selection of the world's most bizarre hotels and resorts.

Watch high quality music videos; jazz, classical, world music and more

Music video downloads

Watch concerts in your living room and download live music videos today.

Search thousands of opportunites in every sector.

560+ construction jobs

Search thousands of opportunites in every sector.

Back to top

More Telegraph.co.uk

Archive Contact us Reader prints RSS feeds Subscribe and save Syndication Today's news

© Copyright of Telegraph Media Group Limited 2009 Terms & Conditions of reading Commercial information Privacy and Cookie Policy.