Skip to content.

omidyar.net

Sections
Personal tools

CompuMentor/TechSoup Project Development

Subsections

Comment by Phil Klein

Author: Phil Klein (37)
Date posted: Fri, 24 Dec 2004 10:30:21 PST
Comment on: Nonprofit Technology Taxonomy Creation (3)
Feedback score: 0 +|-

As a cheap experiment with potential, i think this idea is a good one. In the longer run, I think we should consider some broader issues:

  1. Maybe np, the broader nonprofit sector, would be worth considering, rather than couching things in nptech. imo, there's already a pronounced tech bias in delicious.
  2. limitations of delicious as a tool. What are these and how will these affect the success of this project? multi word taxonomy entries aren't possible in a consistent manner, the 'earlier/later' dichotomy in delicious may not be an appropriate filter on quality and relevance. what's the potential for gaming the system by a small number of people with uncommon interests?
  3. audience. I think we should be clear about the intended audience. IMO, i think that the nptech taxonomy is intended primarily for use by people who work in this field, and secondly by np staff. Maybe this isn't right.
  4. goals. a few goal suggestions:
  • to have a well-organized, self-maintaining bookmark library that we can share.
  • to discern a taxonomy by observing how nptech's classify resources
  • to get a sense of the quantity & diversity of web resources within this nptech field.
back to top of page