The Oakland Tribune
Advertise | Subscribe | Contact Us
 
News | Sports | Business | Op - Ed | Living | Features | Health
Site Search

Enter search term
Advanced Search

Shop local sales
and specials from our
newspapers

News
Local News
Sports
Prep Sports
Bay Area Living
Business
Opinion
Letters to the Editor
Obituaries
Archives

Link To Article   Print Article   Email Article

'Riders' suspect blasts accuser
Fired city cop takes stand, describes life on the force as violent, brutal
By Alex Katz, STAFF WRITER

OAKLAND — Fired Oakland cop Clarence "Chuck" Mabanag used rough language on the stand Tuesday to describe his time on the police force and his training of a rookie cop whose resignation led to two misconduct trials against the so-called Riders.

Mabanag told jurors Tuesday that Keith Batt, the officer who reported alleged misconduct by the Riders after just a few weeks on the job, was small, afraid and unprepared for the violence

and stress of police work.

Mabanag, a former Marine, testified that he used profanity toward Batt in an attempt to humble the recruit and teach him that Oakland can be a harsh city.

"Did you ever call Keith Batt a b---- or a little b----?" defense attorney Mike Rains asked Mabanag.

"Yes, sir, I did," Mabanag said.

Mabanag denied allegations that he doctored a police report about a violent arrest in West Oakland that occurred during Batt's first night on the street.

But Mabanag admitted to "dusting off" the suspect's statements, which he defined as suggesting statements that were favorable toward police.

"Dusting off" reports is standard practice in the police department, Mabanag said.

Three officers known as the Riders — Mabanag, Jude Siapno and Matt Hornung, are   charged with a total of 15 felony counts, including filing false police reports, conspiring to obstruct justice, assault and battery, and kidnapping.

Also charged was former officer Frank Vasquez, who is believed to have fled the country before trial.

The first Riders trial ended last year with the jury acquitting the defendants on eight charges and deadlocking on 27 other counts. Mabanag is accused of teaching rookie officers to rough up drug suspects and then lie about it in reports.

Rains, himself a former cop, portrayed Mabanag as someone well acquainted with the ugly realities of drugs and crime in Oakland.

Mabanag testified that he bought drugs — crack, heroin and pot — dozens of times while working on stings as an undercover officer.

The former officer also told jurors that he shot four suspects, one fatally, during his 11 years on the force.

In 1992, Mabanag killed a man who reportedly pointed a gun at him and another officer from the roof of a building on Pearl Street. While an undercover officer in 1995, Mabanag shot an assault pistol out of the hand of a convicted cocaine dealer in a Fruitvale neighborhood.

Mabanag also testified that he was forced to shoot six dogs while   on the job.

During Batt's first night on the job, Mabanag threatened to shoot another dog, which led to a brawl between the two officers and the dog's owner, Kenneth Soriano.

Mabanag and Batt had arrived at a home on Adeline Street that night to take a police report about a stolen car. Soriano's dog was chained in the yard of the home.

Mabanag testified that he said to Soriano, "I don't want to come in your yard because if your dog gets loose I'll have to shoot it."

Moments later, the officers were struggling with an enraged Soriano, Mabanag said.

Batt, now on the Pleasanton police   force, has testified that Mabanag falsified his report of the fight.

Mabanag denied that, but admitted "dusting off" the report to make Soriano's statements more favorable to officers.

During the arrest, Batt "just looked terrified," Mabanag said. "He was just hanging on Mr. Soriano's arm."

     

RETURN TO TOP

Related Articles
  • Jury selection begins in church sex abuse case
  • Defense motion seeks new trial for Peterson
  • Judge: Ban on gay vows is illegal
  • Gay couples overjoyed with ruling
  • Kimi Nao Matsumoto dies
  • Judge rules nurse ratios must start now
  • Book lends historical perspective to Alta Bates hospitals
  • Ex-coach: Williams' roster spot wasn't set
  • Visitor says sideshow turned violent
  • Port expanding debris recycling
  • Angelides throws hat into gubernatorial ring
  • Off life support, student dies
  • Ceremony, march bless synagogue
  • Money pours in for Cleveland Cascade
  • Charter school plan threatened
  •  border=  border=
    Place a Classified Ad
    Your ad will appear in print
    and online

    Online Only Ads
    Post a Job Ad
    $199 for 30 days

    Post a Rental Ad
    $34.95 for 6 weeks

     
    1993 JEEP Grand Cherokee (Cars)
    Click for Details

    1996 LEXUS ES300 (Cars)
    Click for Details

    2001 Kawsaki Vulcan 500 (Cars)
    Click for Details

    1990 MERCEDES 450 SE (Cars)
    Click for Details

    1996 DODGE Ram Short 1500 (Cars)
    Click for Details

    2000 VW Beetle (Cars)
    Click for Details

    1973 BUICK Riviera (Cars)
    Click for Details

    2003 Chevrolet Avalanche 1500 Sport Utility Pickup 4D (Cars)
    FH Dailey Chevrolet /Isuzu

    All Listings
     
    FOR RENT (Rentals)
    Click for Details

    HAYWARD  (Rentals)
    Click for Details

    TRACY HOME FOR RENT (Rentals)
    Click for Details

    SAN LEANDRO  (Rentals)
    Click for Details

    FOR RENT (Rentals)
    Click for Details

    Apt. for Rent (Rentals)
    Click for Details

    FREMONT FOR RENT (Rentals)
    Click for Details

    OAKLAND (Rentals)
    Click for Details

    All Listings
     
    FEDERAL POSTAL JOBS (Jobs)
    Click for Details

    BANKING  (Jobs)
    Click for Details

    DENTAL  (Jobs)
    Click for Details

    REAL Estate Agent (Jobs)
    Click for Details

    SECURITY (Jobs)
    Click for Details

    Accounting Manager (Jobs)
    Click for Details

    PHYSICAL THERAPY (Jobs)
    Click for Details

    CUSTOMER (Jobs)
    Click for Details

    All Listings
     
    FREMONT HOME FOR SALE (Homes)
    Click for Details

    HOME FOR SALE (Homes)
    Click for Details

    San Leandro Home For Sale (Homes)
    Click for Details

    TRACY HOME FOR RENT (Homes)
    Click for Details

    HOME FOR SALE (Homes)
    Click for Details

    Riverbank hm for sale (Homes)
    Click for Details

    OAKLAND RETAIL SPACE FOR RENT (Homes)
    Click for Details

    WEST OAKLAND DUPLEX FOR SALE (Homes)
    Click for Details

    All Listings
    InsideBayArea.com home
    The Oakland Tribune | Alameda Times-Star | The Argus | The Daily Review | Marin Independent Journal
    San Mateo County Times | Tri-Valley Herald | Vallejo Times-Herald | Milpitas Post | Pacifica Tribune

    Business | Sports | Shop | Cars | Homes | Jobs | Community

    ANG Newspapers | Job Opportunities | Home Delivery | Feedback | Contact Us

    © 2005 ANG Newspapers