By the River Piedra I Sat Down and Wept: A Novel of Forgiveness (P.S.)
by Paulo Coelho (Goodreads author!)
|
|
Sign in to Goodreads to see your friends reviews of By the River Piedra I Sat Down and Wept: A Novel of Forgiveness.
discuss this book
new topic
| topics | replies | last activity |
|---|---|---|
| amir kianafraz | 1 | 13 days ago, 11:16AM |
| Paulo Coelho Group | 1 | 10/23/2007 04:05AM |
groups with this book
friend reviews (0)
To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
other reviews
Read in November, 2005
I have just experienced a wonderful and enlightening love story that has moved me deeply. Indeed, Paulo Coelho's "By The River Piedra I Sat Down And Wept" is a must read for people who have lost, found, or still seeking for love.
I have made some references to this novel in some of my past blogs. But now, I am writing more about it on my personal realizations after experiencing this enigmatic literary work.
I have jotted down some lines from the book that struck me the most, ...more
I have made some references to this novel in some of my past blogs. But now, I am writing more about it on my personal realizations after experiencing this enigmatic literary work.
I have jotted down some lines from the book that struck me the most, ...more
Like this review?
vote
(2 people liked it)
1 comments
Read in December, 2007
Most people enter the world of Paulo Coelho with Alchemist. I started with "Veronika decides to die" and then moved on to "By the river Piedra I sat down and wept".
I am just starting to read the Alchemist.
I really, really, loved the Veronika - it was an easy read with the very deep meaning that I could very much relate to.
I started reading By the River having the same expectations...and was a little bit disappointed, and this is why I gave this book 4 starts and not...more
I am just starting to read the Alchemist.
I really, really, loved the Veronika - it was an easy read with the very deep meaning that I could very much relate to.
I started reading By the River having the same expectations...and was a little bit disappointed, and this is why I gave this book 4 starts and not...more
Like this review?
vote
add a comment
Paulo Coelho is one of my favorite writers, and this is the book where he hooked me for good.
The book tells the story of the cynical, urban working girl Pilar, who runs into her childhood best friend after many years and discovers a couple of pretty astonishing things, all right in a row: A) that he's been in love with her all his life, B) that he's entered the seminary, C) that he belongs to a strange spiritual cult dedicated to worshiping the feminine face of God, and D) that he can perfor...more
The book tells the story of the cynical, urban working girl Pilar, who runs into her childhood best friend after many years and discovers a couple of pretty astonishing things, all right in a row: A) that he's been in love with her all his life, B) that he's entered the seminary, C) that he belongs to a strange spiritual cult dedicated to worshiping the feminine face of God, and D) that he can perfor...more
Like this review?
vote
add a comment
Read in August, 2006
all i can say is.. i can totally relate to the book when i read it.. :p
the book tells a story about a young girl whose old flame was rekindled when she met her long lost friend. unfortunately, the friend is a would-be priest. it's funny when sometimes people do illogical things when it comes to love. she knew the consequences of falling in love with the man, of how her heart would be broken, and yet she was unable to stop herself, and continued to love him anyway.
Here are some of my favour...more
the book tells a story about a young girl whose old flame was rekindled when she met her long lost friend. unfortunately, the friend is a would-be priest. it's funny when sometimes people do illogical things when it comes to love. she knew the consequences of falling in love with the man, of how her heart would be broken, and yet she was unable to stop herself, and continued to love him anyway.
Here are some of my favour...more
Like this review?
vote
add a comment
Read in August, 2007
اطلاع كامل از دين مسحيت لازمه درك درست اين كتابه كه متاسفانه من فاقد اين علم بودماما در كل مزمون عشق اون هم در يك سري اتفاقات پي در پي آدم رو گيچ ميكنه و صد البته مشتاق گويا اين اثر قلم كوئيلو هستش كه اين حالت رو در خواننده ايجاد ميكنه
املا در مورد خود داستان ميتونم به مواردي كه ...more
املا در مورد خود داستان ميتونم به مواردي كه ...more
Like this review?
vote
add a comment
Read in January, 2008
recommends it for:
no one
I read about a quarter of the book, but it is basically referencing ideas of an Earth Mother, Goddess, Virgin Mother rubbish that made it impossible for me to swallow any of the rest of what I gather is a love story.
I remember enjoying The Alchemist by the same author, read years ago, but this novel with it's ideas of the feminine face of God and its shmatltzy Hallmark sayings of love and discovery were cheap. What annoyed me, and should have clued me in, was the authors note at the start o...more
I remember enjoying The Alchemist by the same author, read years ago, but this novel with it's ideas of the feminine face of God and its shmatltzy Hallmark sayings of love and discovery were cheap. What annoyed me, and should have clued me in, was the authors note at the start o...more
Like this review?
vote
add a comment
Read in September, 2007
A story about love and faith. When combined, they conquer all. It also goes into the feminine side of religions that are not often talked about, and how the symbol for the feminine body in faith is water. Interesting views.
Some Favorite Quotes:
"True love is an act of total surrender."
"The more we love, the closer we come to spiritual experience."
"In fairy tales, the princesses kiss the frogs, and the frogs become princes. In real life, the princesses ki...more
Some Favorite Quotes:
"True love is an act of total surrender."
"The more we love, the closer we come to spiritual experience."
"In fairy tales, the princesses kiss the frogs, and the frogs become princes. In real life, the princesses ki...more
Like this review?
vote
add a comment
Read in September, 2007
Gw kebetulan baca novel ini yang terjemahan bahasa indonesianya (secara kalo baca englishnya bisa 10 tahun!)
Novel ini merupakan bagian awal dari trilogi-nya Paulo yaitu:
- By the River Piedra I Sat Down and Wept
- Veronika Decides to Die
- The Fifth Mountain
Novel ini terbit tahun 1992, jauh sebelum The Da Vinci Code beredar. Tapi buku ini mempunyai kesamaan inti cerita, yaitu tentang Tuhan. Dalam buku ini dibahas tentang sisi feminin Tuhan yang kita kenal selama ini dari sisi maskulin...more
Novel ini merupakan bagian awal dari trilogi-nya Paulo yaitu:
- By the River Piedra I Sat Down and Wept
- Veronika Decides to Die
- The Fifth Mountain
Novel ini terbit tahun 1992, jauh sebelum The Da Vinci Code beredar. Tapi buku ini mempunyai kesamaan inti cerita, yaitu tentang Tuhan. Dalam buku ini dibahas tentang sisi feminin Tuhan yang kita kenal selama ini dari sisi maskulin...more
Like this review?
vote
add a comment
به نقل از سایت انتشارات کاروان
سایت رسمی پائولو کوئلیو به زبان فارسی
پیلار تصور می‌کند تمام آن چه را که در زندگی برایش اهمیت داشته، در یک هفته، سخاوتمندانه به او ارزانی شد...more
سایت رسمی پائولو کوئلیو به زبان فارسی
پیلار تصور می‌کند تمام آن چه را که در زندگی برایش اهمیت داشته، در یک هفته، سخاوتمندانه به او ارزانی شد...more
Like this review?
vote
add a comment
سعی کن زندگی کنی خاطره مال پیرمردها و پیر زنهاست.
خداوند هر روز لحظه ای را به مه می بخشد که در آن می توانیم هر آنجه را که ما را ناشاد می کند دگرگون کتیم.
خدا همان است، هرچند هزار نام دارد، اما آدمی باید نامی را انتخاب کند تا او را به آن بخواند.
اگر کسی ما را بخواهد همه ما را میخواه...more
خداوند هر روز لحظه ای را به مه می بخشد که در آن می توانیم هر آنجه را که ما را ناشاد می کند دگرگون کتیم.
خدا همان است، هرچند هزار نام دارد، اما آدمی باید نامی را انتخاب کند تا او را به آن بخواند.
اگر کسی ما را بخواهد همه ما را میخواه...more
Like this review?
vote
add a comment
Read in January, 2000
Weepy, yes. Kinda made my heart throb. Ache, rather. I had this book photocopied and bound so I could share with someone. I must have wanted so badly to rub away the hurt and the coldness that swept through me while I was reading this sappy Coelho book-- I spilled Efficascent Oil all over the bound pages. Seven years later, I bought a new copy. Took me that long to forgive.
I have yet to reread the book, but I expect that like before, it will be another emotional journey. For those of you wh...more
I have yet to reread the book, but I expect that like before, it will be another emotional journey. For those of you wh...more
Like this review?
vote
add a comment
Has a copy to sell/swap
—
Read in October, 2006
lumayan kaget melihat review yang bagus di good reads tentang buku ini.Saya beli buku ini karena it's one of coelho's and it was supposed to be good. tapi entah kenapa, i've never finish reading this book. Setelah halaman ke- (kurang dari sepuluh) saya mengantuk dan terlalu malas untuk mengulang membacanya kembali. Nggak tau ya, mungkin karena pembukaannya tidak catchy/kurang menarik, atau terjemahannya yang butut yang bikin saya tidak tertarik sama sekali untuk menyelesaikan membacanya.
tapi m...more
tapi m...more
Like this review?
vote
add a comment
Read in May, 2006
recommends it for:
semua orang yang butuh kekuatan
udah lama banget baca buku ini, dan emang butuh waktu dan konsentrasi mendalam ama buku ini..
Tapi baca bab pembukanya aja, elo semua bakal termehek2 bacanya dan banyak pelajaran tentang cinta di dalamnya...
Dan bagaimana arti cinta sebenernya... bukan cinta yang anget2 tai kucing hehehe ( maksudnya yang hangat2 awalnya doang dan setelah itu merasa kehilangan makna).. Tapi cinta itu juga memaafkan dan menerima apa adanya... Yaitu mengambil sepercik sayang Tuhan untuk kita bagi dengan manusia...more
Tapi baca bab pembukanya aja, elo semua bakal termehek2 bacanya dan banyak pelajaran tentang cinta di dalamnya...
Dan bagaimana arti cinta sebenernya... bukan cinta yang anget2 tai kucing hehehe ( maksudnya yang hangat2 awalnya doang dan setelah itu merasa kehilangan makna).. Tapi cinta itu juga memaafkan dan menerima apa adanya... Yaitu mengambil sepercik sayang Tuhan untuk kita bagi dengan manusia...more
Like this review?
vote
add a comment
Read in December, 2007
"Rarely do we realize that we are in the midst of the extraordinary. Miracles occur all around us, signs from God show us the way, angels plead to be heard, but we pay little attentions to them because we have been taught that we must follow certain formulas and rules if we want to find God."
"A fall from the third floor hurts as much as a fall from the hundredth. If I fall, may it be from a high place."
"Only a man who is happy can create happiness in others.&qu;...more
"A fall from the third floor hurts as much as a fall from the hundredth. If I fall, may it be from a high place."
"Only a man who is happy can create happiness in others.&qu;...more
Like this review?
vote
add a comment
Read in February, 2007
I don't recall the characters and the story exactly (my memory is jogged by other goodreads' members' reviews, though).
What I most remember about this book is that it celebrates the feminine principle of God. For about a week after I finished the book, my prayers were often automagically addressed to God as the Divine Feminine. Which to one reared as a Lutheran was both curious and confusing.
Attitude in which to read this novel: Curiosity, Spiritual Seeking, Fed up with the Status Quo, See...more
What I most remember about this book is that it celebrates the feminine principle of God. For about a week after I finished the book, my prayers were often automagically addressed to God as the Divine Feminine. Which to one reared as a Lutheran was both curious and confusing.
Attitude in which to read this novel: Curiosity, Spiritual Seeking, Fed up with the Status Quo, See...more
Like this review?
vote
add a comment
Read in November, 2007
The second Paulo Coehlo book I had read after The Valkyries. Unfortunately, like The Valkyries, I am also not impressed with this one.
Why? Well, when I started reading the book, I was feeling nothing. When I finished reading it, I still felt nothing. In other words, it made no impact whatsoever. I also found the book's tone quite preachy about spirituality, religion, and mysticism...
Strike 2 for Paulo Coehlo! *Sighs*
Why? Well, when I started reading the book, I was feeling nothing. When I finished reading it, I still felt nothing. In other words, it made no impact whatsoever. I also found the book's tone quite preachy about spirituality, religion, and mysticism...
Strike 2 for Paulo Coehlo! *Sighs*
Like this review?
vote
add a comment
Read in August, 2007
surprised that it tackled religion, though with a really risky concept. on the other hand, the book really is inspirational (a self-help covered in fictional story). i don't think every people will like the book. if you are coelho fan, definitely you will like it. but depending on what situation you are in at the moment, the book somehow affects you and makes you want to look back into your life and reflect.
Like this review?
vote
add a comment
در زندگی چیزهایی هست که ارزشش را دارند که آدم تا آخر خط برایشان بجنگد.....با رنج گذشته در باره عشق آینده قضاوت نکن ...عشق همیشه تازه است ...مهم نیست یک بار دو بار سه بار در زندگی عاشق شویم چون همیشه در وضعیتی قرار میگیریم که نمیشناسیم
Like this review?
vote
add a comment
Read in August, 2006
A love story telling of two sweethearts who at age 18 separate, when he goes on to travel the world and become a priest. She stays home to go to college and develop relationships with friends locally. They connect at one of his speeches and spend a week together falling in love and deciding to spend the rest of their lives together. A deep, philosophical, compelling poetic novel.
Like this review?
vote
add a comment
more than a journey-styled novel, this Coelho's is not only telling about forgiveness. forgiveness itself is a part of a holy divine subject of the almighty. this is called feminist side of god.
In most civilizations, god often be manifested in the form of a Father. but, trough this journey-novel, Coelho giving us the other form of god as a mother who takes care and loves us.
In most civilizations, god often be manifested in the form of a Father. but, trough this journey-novel, Coelho giving us the other form of god as a mother who takes care and loves us.
Like this review?
vote
add a comment
book data (includes all editions)
avg rating (all editions): 3.46 (2865 ratings) avg rating (this edition): 3.53 (2202 ratings) number of reviews: 224popular bookshelves
to-read (7)currently-reading (2)
read (2)
understanding (1)
e-book (1)
coelho (1)
inspiring (1)
paulo-coelho (1)
super-keeper (-1)
other editions (44) (edit)
