Skip to content
Click on cover to enlarge
photograph by Björn Goldhausen

Struck By Lightning

«  page 2 of 3  »

It’s random and electric, and we are forever drawn to its deadly charms

by Jill Frayne

photograph by Björn Goldhausen

Published in the Escape: Summer 2008 issue.  » BUY ISSUE     

          Facebook         Stumble      Get The Walrus on your Blackberry or Windows Mobile        RSS


We are rather susceptible in Canada. Our country is mostly landscape, and we’re often roaming around it, beyond broadcast areas, beyond cover. To prepare ourselves, we have to be our own Environment Canada: we have to learn the rudiments of storms, know the terrain we’re travelling through, be able to tell a front from a squall line, a stratus cloud from a nimbus. Thunderstorms do give notice — wickedly short, usually, but always distinctive. After my brush on Georgian Bay, I boned up, taking myself to the You and Your World shelf at the library.

Storms rely on the rapid, sustained uplifting of air, especially warm, moist air. This is why they occur frequently in summer, when the ground has grown hot by late afternoon. Open fields heat faster than forests or water, rocky slopes faster than ground covered by vegetation; hence the sudden onrush of the storm we experienced, parked on the warm rock enfolding Georgian Bay, just at cocktail hour at the end of a hot day.

Convection fuels thunderstorms, either from warm air rising off the ground, or from a drop in temperature in the atmosphere. Cheery, popcorn white clouds in the sky mean unstable air has stopped rising and has reached the dew point, when its temperature equals that of the surrounding air. These cumulus clouds can persist for days or they can dissipate, but if warm thermal air keeps pushing up, they often develop into cumulonimbus clouds. When this happens, an aerial game of pinball begins. Droplets bounce around, collide, pick up grit, old volcanic ash, the detritus of life below, all of it freezing into ice crystals in the troposphere. Air travellers experience this as turbulence, their plane passing through cumulonimbus clouds, lurching in the chaos, the cabin windows dashed with rain or hail, until the aircraft emerges from the cloud.

On the ground, this intense interior action looks like a change from roly-poly clouds jogging in the sky to clouds darkening and mounting into towers. This formation means a storm is brewing. Inside the cloud, ice crystals and raindrops zing about in all directions, slamming into and fusing with one another, growing larger and heavier, until they start falling through the cloud as rain or snow or hail.

Lightning gets into the action through an electrical charge that builds during these high-wire collisions. When a beauty of a storm is brewing, a negative charge heats up at the base of the cloud. The earth’s surface tends to be negatively charged, and since like charges repel, current at the bottom of the cloud draws away from the ground, leaving a positive charge in the air. This is that pre-storm sense one gets, the hair on the head lifting slightly, the air freighted with electricity.

It’s in the nature of air to act as a buffer, to resist electrical flow, and for a time it contains the mounting charge. But it can’t hold out forever. At a certain point, the negative charge from the cloud expends itself, not all at once, which would be an atomic reaction, but haltingly, in a “stepped leader” about as thick as a pencil. This negative charge gropes toward the ground, moving in a searching way, like a lonely drunk in a bar looking for a connection. Eventually, it attracts a positive charge from something tall on the ground — a tree or a tower, a farmer on a tractor. When lightning strikes, the charges have connected in a streamer, a flood of positive current that surges back up into the cloud, spectacularly hot, so intensely superheating the surrounding air that a shock wave bulges out, faster than the speed of sound.

Thunder is the sonic boom we hear when the percussive force breaks the sound barrier. Once the stepped leader from the cloud locks to the streamer from the ground, a channel opens for pulses of electricity to pass through, producing several flashes. We see the lightning before we hear the boom, but the thunder actually occurs first; the speed of light outraces the sound of thunder to our senses.

In its defence, lightning is only doing its job. It’s the celestial housekeeper, balancing an overcharged heaven and earth.

I am standing on the north shore of Lake Superior beside my kayak, debating whether to make the twelve-kilometre crossing to the Slate Islands. The steep spruce hills on the islands are criss-crossed with caribou trails, and the wild, broken beaches on the south side face an infinity of sky and water. I’m alone, a competent paddler used to solo travel, vigilant and informed about the genesis of storms, and I’m longing to go. In the morning, I tune in to a broadcast: there’s a storm watch in effect. Driving up the day before, I noticed the blue sky beginning to sprout low cumulus clouds. Today the clouds are more altocumulus, mid-level, joined like loaves of bread. The sun is shining, but the sky to the west has a purple tinge, and a wind is gathering. It’s the height of summer. If there are clouds in the morning, an afternoon storm is a probability. Do I have time to cross?

Paddling at six kilometres an hour, I need two hours when I’m not in the storm radius and not the tallest object in this watery field. I’ve almost decided to chance it when I glimpse a flash of lightning, lovely and silent on the violet horizon to the west. There’s no thunder, which means the storm is at least sixteen kilometres off, but that’s no comfort. Lightning is so volatile it can easily strike ahead of the thunderheads from that distance. Another flash, with time-delayed thunder following. I apply the old “flash-bang” guideline, count the interval between seeing the flash and hearing the bang, divide my count, in this case twenty seconds, by five, and calculate that the storm is four miles, or six kilometres, away. I wait and count the next round, with the same result. This could mean the storm is stalled, but it might not. I glance at the enticing bulk of the Slates across the channel and know I’m not going. I’ll have to wait until whatever is coming has passed.

Comments (7 comments)

John G: A few weeks ago I was mowing the lawn on a humid Saturday, rushing to finish before the approaching storm. You're right to take the advice that if you can hear it or see it, then you are in striking distance. The bolt wasn't blue, however what I saw was a bright flesh-like redness, the same colour one might see if you shine a flash-light through your hand in the dark... I figured that I had blinked at the moment when it hit the neighbor's aluminum roof and traveled to the nearby ground. It happened, of course, extremely fast. Leaving me to question if it had happened at all, that is until the neighbor came rushing out thinking I'd just been killed. Needless to say the lawn remained 9/10ths finished as I reflected on what had just occurred. July 12, 2008 19:32 EST

John G: ...
Struck by lightning on camera
http://www.flickr.com/photos/i_love_the_slow_loris/2646424593/ July 16, 2008 18:48 EST

Rakesh Das: The article is excellent. It has focussed on the science of lightning in a very interesting way. Geographical and astronomical phenomena interests me a lot as I am doing my masters in Geography. This article has really helped me a lot. I was not aware of many static facts like speed of lightning, temperature etc. I wonder if earth is struck many times a day by lightning, why scientists are not getting success in generating electricity from it? If we can handle huge temperature and high radiation from nuclear fission reaction then why can't lightning by designing vast conductors in storm prone area. Its a paradox ! August 06, 2008 07:32 EST

Ian Baines: I am writing this from my storm swept island in Georgian Bay - where the kind of sudden tempest described is very common. In our case, we can hear the thunder 40 - 60 km away, as both heard outside and seen on Environment Canada's weather radar system. The benefits of having satellite internet on so remote a rock.
Generally the lightning does give lots of warning, with the towering black clouds and ominous rumbles. Commuting via boat; we do take these things seriously.

I have experienced a bolt from the blue, however. My home in Burlington is equipped with lightning rods, as is the island cottage. I expected the cottage to get hit, but not the home. In fact, both my Burlington homes have been hit, and both times the lightning rods worked.

My daughter used our backyard swimming pool to run a swimming lesson business for five summers. She would stop all lessons at the first sound of thunder, as she should. One clear afternoon at about 3:30 she was in the pool with two small children. No warning thunder and no ominous black clouds. Just a bolt from the blue.

It exploded against the chimney lightning rod with a bang that brought neighbours running. The flash was intense and one person saw a blue flash arc across the lawn away from the pool. The distance from pool and children to the rod was twenty feet. Without that rod to intercept the strike......

No, lightning rods don't attract lightning. At least not unless it is within 50 m of the ground and impact is imminent. So without the rod, the fence, pool, diving board, or anything else could have been hit. The odds of surviving are pretty much zero. With the rod, the downcomer cable took the hit, the ground system dissipated the charge safely on the other side of the house and the blue flash across the lawn traced the path of the excessive charge that could not dissipate in the earth fast enough.

The only damage was from a pencil sized hole in the rod, burned paint along the side of the house, and three very badly frightened people.

August 09, 2008 12:53 EST

mike w: I recently drove over a mountain in New Hampshire and found that I had driven directly into a lighting storm. I was driving a motorcycle at the time. I couldn't go back up the mountain, I didn't want to hide in the trees, so I just kept going forward and praying. I have never been so scared in my life.
Thank you for this article Ms. Frayne I love your writing. August 15, 2008 15:57 EST

Anonymous: Not so smart Mike! I love riding in the rain but I try to avoid it for that reason.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=exoz0B6JvRw

Great article! August 31, 2008 09:52 EST

Heinz R.: I'm an electrical engineer who lives in what is usually called the lightning capital of the USA, in Central Florida. From time to time I lecture on lightning, including the limited means available to reduce the probabilties of death, injury or property damage, to communities, civic organizations and municipalities. It is remarkable that with all the advances science has made in the past 250 years that the best design for an air terminal (usually called a lightning protector) is still pretty much Ben Franklin's design of around 1750; in fact, it's called a Franklin terminal. Of course, there are some additional measures available to protect equipment, but in the final analysis nothing is perfect. A direct strike will vaporize pretty much most everything.
I would like to commend Ms. Frayne for an article accurate in its description of lightning science and its recommendations, free of the usual myths that accompany any discussion of lightning, particularly the ones that metal "atracts" lightning or that rubber sneakers or vehicle tires can insulate from lighting.
Thank you for a job well done!
October 10, 2008 04:47 EST

Comment on this article


Will not be displayed on the site

Submit a comment online

Submit a letter to the Editor


    Cancel

The Walrus E-Newsletter

Online exclusives, events, offers:
get news of everything Walrus.