Argument from fallacy

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This article does not cite any references or sources. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed. (December 2008)

The argument from fallacy, also known as argumentum ad logicam or fallacy fallacy, is a logical fallacy which assumes that if an argument is fallacious, its conclusion must be false. A fallacious argument can still have a true conclusion; the existence of the fallacy only means that the conclusion isn't guaranteed to be true.

Contents 1 Form 2 Examples 3 Explanation 4 References 5 See also

[edit] Form

It has the general argument form:

If P, then Q.

P is a fallacious argument.

Therefore, Q is false.

[edit] Examples

Examples:

Tom: "All cats are animals. Ginger is an animal. This means Ginger is a cat.".

Bill: "Ah you just committed the affirming the consequent logical fallacy. Sorry, you are wrong, which means that Ginger is not a cat".

Tom: "OK — I'll prove I'm English — I speak English so that proves it".

Bill: "But Americans and Canadians, among others, speak English too. You have committed the package-deal fallacy, assuming that speaking English and being English always go together. That means you are not English".

Of course, the mere fact that the argument from fallacy can be invoked against a position does not automatically "prove" the position either, as this would itself be yet another argument from fallacy. An example of this false reasoning follows:

Joe: Bill's assumption that Ginger is not a cat uses the argument from fallacy. Therefore, Ginger absolutely must be a cat.

[edit] Explanation

The argumentum ad logicam can be seen as a variant of the ad hominem fallacy, because it relies on the opposing speaker's seeming lack of credibility, a factor which is usually irrelevant to the actual correctness of a given theory (although it can help bolster the evidence in an inductive argument).

[edit] References

• Fallacy Fallacy The Fallacy Files

[edit] See also

• Argument from ignorance (Argumentum ad ignorantiam)
• Straw Man

v • d • e Formal fallacies Argument from fallacy • Fallacy of modal logic • Masked man fallacy • Appeal to probability • Bare assertion fallacy Fallacy of propositional logic: Affirming a disjunct • Affirming the consequent • False dilemma • Denying the antecedent Fallacy of quantificational logic: Existential fallacy • Illicit Conversion • Proof by example • Quantifier shift Syllogistic fallacy: Affirmative conclusion from a negative premise • Exclusive premises • Necessity • Four-term Fallacy • Illicit major • Illicit minor • Undistributed middle List of fallacies (formal and informal) • Other types of formal fallacy