The Mumbai atrocity is a wake-up call for a frighteningly unprepared Britain
Last updated at 5:30 PM on 01st December 2008
Around the world, people have reacted with horror to the vile atrocities in Mumbai.
For three days, our TV screens transmitted images of carnage and chaos as the toll of murder victims climbed to upwards of 190 people, with many hundreds more injured.
Despite the fact that British citizens were caught up in the attacks, there is nevertheless a sense in Britain that this was nothing to do with us - a horrible event happening in a faraway place.
The Taj Mahal Hotel in Mumbai: 'We don't understand what we are up against... if it were to happen here, we would be unable to cope'
Among commentators, moreover, there has been no small amount of confusion.
Were these terrorists motivated by the grievance between Muslims and Hindus over Kashmir, or was this a broader attack by Al Qaeda?
If British and American tourists were singled out over Iraq - which many assume is the motive for such attacks - why were Indians targeted in the Victoria railway station?
And why was an obscure Jewish outreach centre marked for slaughter?
Such perceptions and questions suggest that, even now, Western commentators still don't grasp what the free world is facing. This was not merely a distant horror.
We should pay the closest possible attention to what happened in Mumbai because something on this scale could well happen here.
Fanatics
But because we don't understand what we are actually up against, we are not doing nearly enough to prevent this - or something even worse - occurring on British soil; and if it were to happen here, we would be unable to cope.
The Mumbai atrocities show very clearly what too many in Britain obdurately deny - that a war is being waged against civilisation.
It is both global and local. It is not 'our' fault; it has nothing to do with Muslim poverty, oppression or discrimination.
The Islamic fundamentalist fanatics use specific grievances - Kashmir, Iraq, Palestine, Chechnya - merely as recruiting sergeants for their worldwide holy war against all 'unbelievers'.
The only militant to survive the attack, who says he is from Kashmir
The Mumbai attackers targeted British, American and Indian citizens simply because they wanted to kill as many British, American and Indian 'unbelievers' as possible.
Where they found Muslims, they spared them.
They also singled out for slaughter the occupants of the Chabad House, a pious Jewish outreach organisation with no Israeli or political agenda - underscoring the point that at the core of the Islamists' hatred of Israel festers their hatred of the Jews.
This was not, as is so often described, 'mindless violence'.
On the contrary, the terrorists precisely calibrated both their choice of targets and the way in which they attacked them. This tells us many things.
India was chosen in order to further two aims. First was to foment greater tension between India and Pakistan.
No less important was the wish to destroy the ever more vital strategic alliance between India and the West in common defence against the Islamist onslaught.
That was why British and American visitors in those two grand hotels were singled out.
And that was why Mumbai itself was chosen - as the symbol of India's burgeoning commerce and prosperity and its links with the West.
The manner of these attacks also carried a message.
Many hostages were taken, but no attempt was made to use them to demand redress of any grievances. They were simply killed.
That made a statement that the terrorists' agenda is non-negotiable.
The attacks demonstrated, above all, the reach of the perpetrators and the impotence of their designated victims.
Those who believe that Islamist terror can be halted by addressing grievances around the world are profoundly mistaken.
With these atrocities, moreover, Islamist attacks have moved much closer to war than conventional terrorism.
The Iranian-born foreign affairs specialist Amir Taheri has pointed out that the Mumbai attacks embody the plan outlined by a senior Al Qaeda strategist after the U.S. decided to fight back following 9/11 - a decision that the Islamists had not expected.
This new strategy entails targeting countries with a substantial Muslim presence for 'low-intensity warfare' comprising bombings, kidnappings, the taking of hostages, the use of women and children as human shields, beheadings and other attacks that make normal life impossible.
Onslaught
Such a simultaneous, multi-faceted onslaught quickly reduces a city and a country to chaos. It can be repeated anywhere - and British cities must be among the most vulnerable.
This is because - astoundingly - Britain now harbours the most developed infrastructure of Islamist terrorism and extremism in the Western world.
The security service has warned that it is monitoring at least 2,000 known terrorists, and has said repeatedly that although many outrages have been averted a major attack may not be preventable.
Indeed, British security officials have sleepless nights about the various ways in which the Islamists are trying to cause mass casualties in Britain - and the fact that even now this threat is not taken seriously.
This point was made yesterday by the former head of Scotland Yard's Counter Terrorism Command, Peter Clarke.
As an example, he noted that Kazi Nurur Rahman, a convicted terrorist who was arrested shortly after 7/7 with a machine-gun and 3,000 rounds of ammunition, had been trying to buy machine-guns, rocket-propelled grenades and missiles - undoubtedly for use against British targets.
Far from the popular caricatures of bumbling, impressionable and socially alienated misfits, he said, there was a capable and motivated enemy spanning the globe which would try to replicate the Mumbai atrocities in Britain.
More from Melanie Phillips...
- MELANIE PHILLIPS: An amnesty for illegal immigrants? What staggering stupidity, Boris 23/11/08
- MELANIE PHILLIPS: The liberals who did so much to destroy the family must share the blame for Baby P 16/11/08
- MELANIE PHILLIPS: Beware this Saudi deal to help bail out Britain. It comes with a devastating IOU 09/11/08
- MELANIE PHILLIPS: One more celebrity cocaine confession - and the shameful truth about the great drugs disaster 02/11/08
- MELANIE PHILLIPS: Gloating cruelty, foul vulgarity and a shameful BBC 27/10/08
- Labour have said the unsayable on migration. But do they really have the guts to crack down? 20/10/08
- MELANIE PHILIPS: Everyone is out to destroy Palin - but it's Obama's past we should examine 12/10/08
- MELANIE PHILLIPS: We must never let Brussels turn Holocaust denial into a crime 05/10/08
- VIEW FULL ARCHIVE
Even more chilling was the warning by a former head of the SAS that Britain has made no adequate preparations to deal with such an onslaught upon a British city - even though that is precisely the ' Doomsday scenario' that the security world fears.
Such synchronised attacks, he said, required a 'military-type response', either by squads of soldiers or armed police. But we have neither in place.
This country is simply not trained, equipped or prepared in any way to deal with something on this scale.
Misguided
Yesterday, Gordon Brown said that the Mumbai attacks had raised 'huge questions' about how the world should address violent extremism.
But the first question he must answer is how the British approach will now change.
For the fact is that not only is Britain hopelessly unprepared for attacks of this kind, but the Government's approach to the problem of home-grown radicalisation is misguided.
Wrongly believing that it can use religious fundamentalists to counter terrorist recruitment and that it must at all costs avoid causing offence, it is failing to stop extremists spreading their propaganda, handling their demands with kid gloves and undermining genuine moderates among Britain's Muslims who have been left exposed, vulnerable and abandoned.
The reason for such flawed policies is the false analysis on which they are based.
The Government and security establishment refuse to acknowledge that what we are facing is a religious war.
Instead, they think that Islamist terrorism is driven by grievances which are basically the fault of the West.
But you have only to look around the world or at the history of the past four decades and more to see the absurdity and ignorance of this view.
Look at Thailand, for example, currently convulsed by Islamist terrorism in the south with bombings, beheadings and the murder of Buddhists.
Look at the persecution of Christians in Nigeria. Look at the Islamist terrorism in the Philippines.
Look, as Peter Clarke noted, at the attacks variously upon New York, Bali, Istanbul, Jakarta, Sharm el Sheikh, Casablanca, Madrid, London and India.
If we don't understand what we are fighting, we cannot defeat it. Mumbai is yet another wake-up call - to a Britain that is still in a trance of denial.
Share this article:
Here's what readers have had to say so far. Why not add your thoughts below?
What is happenning is that Islam has been hijacked by a sizeable minority of radicals. The vast majority of Muslims truly follow the Koran which says peace is the way to salvation.
What we don't need is yet more laws forced upon us and then used incorrectly - as we've seen with the terror laws enacted in the wake of July 7th: used against Iceland and over-stuffed bins, for example. What we do need is for the government to wake up - come down hard against incitement, come down hard on fundraising for these groups under the guise of social welfare, segregate extremists in prison so they cannot spread their hatred. We hear all the time about how the silent majority condemns these attacks - we're not going to alienate them by rooting out the evil in their midst: and if we do, then they were not that condemnatory of such attacks in the first place. Stop appeasing and placating - take a hard line. This is the UK. We have a state religion, but we allow other religions the right to practice - in fact, this is enshrined by law. But this doesn't mean other religions can seek to dominate us through threats or attacks - and the government should stand firm against them
Add your comment
FEMAIL TODAY
- Is this the worst piece of airbrushing ever? Mel B's hips disappear in new advert Looks like an artist with Ultimo underwear got a little carried away
- Eliminated Christine Bleakley racks up a £4,500 bar bill at Mahiki after performing her last tango in Strictly Adrian Chiles went along to help commisserate
- After that disastrous X Factor performance, Britney high-tails it to New York She mimed, was booed and jetted home leaving upset fans behind her
- 'Cheating' Gordon Ramsay plays the family man in cheesy TV ad featuring wife Tana and four children The TV chef displays impeccable timing...
- Strictly survivor Rachel is 'so determined' to get to the final... because the dancing's doing wonders for her figure And she wore a strapless dress to prove it
- What split? Dannii Minogue parades her rugby player beau The Aussie was all smilies and puppy dog eyes in a low-cut gown at the Children's Baftas
- Simon Cowell 'completely freaked out' after his £140k Bentley is bugged The pop mogul's security team found a tracking device under his car
- While mummy's away, daddy Becks is left holding the babies (and they're running riot!) The little ones proved a real handful on a boys' outing to the basketball
- Feeling all white? Nicola Roberts looks queasy after rollercoaster ride with mystery man The singer looked paler than ever at a winter fair
- Geri is more Cheeky Girl than Spice Girl in a transparent red dress Miss Halliwell gave a glimpse of her bottom as she did a twirl at the Children's Baftas
- Worse-for-wear Alesha Dixon celebrates chart success by cavorting with TWO men The 30-year-old star left Movida looking a little tipsy at 3.30am
- Angelina Jolie shows off her flat stomach proving she's NOT pregnant The mother-of-six pulled on a slim-fitting tailored dress in New Orleans
- How the NHS betrayed Alzheimer's patients: As services are slashed, the Mail launches Christmas appeal
- Heads FINALLY roll over Baby P... but will arrogant social services boss get a hefty pay-off?
- Labour 'plot' to save the Speaker: Leaked email reveals secret Michael Martin meeting
- Arranged marriage wife 'murdered husband with her lover'
- Home Office 'mole' breaks cover to 'set the record straight' over Tory MP leaks
- No.10 hints at review of police powers as Sir Ian Blair's replacement faces calls to quit
- BBC in new decency row after John Barrowman exposes himself during live broadcast
- GP 'groped patient's breasts while operating computer'
- Parents' anger at Lapland theme park which turned out to be a muddy field
- Relate counsellor sacked for refusing to give sex therapy to gay couples because he was Christian
- Crisis-hit school facing closure spends £100,000 on toilets that play classical music to pupils
- Two St Bernards die after 100 are rescued from appalling conditions at abandoned kennels
- Man charged with arson - for lighting Guy Fawkes bonfire on village green
- Civil servant 'hacked son of ex-lover to death in revenge after she ended affair'
- Axe falls on 1,350 jobs as Aston Martin, HSBC and Halfords announce cuts
- City banker pays £50,000 to become world's first 'affordable' space tourist
- Tourists warned to stay away from Venice after city suffers worst flooding in 30 years
- Snow storms set to bring travel chaos to Britain as cold snap continues
- Schoolgirl Vicky Hamilton was murdered by handyman in 'barbaric act of unspeakable horror,' jury told as trial reaches closing stages
- Muslim peer banned from driving after sending text message moments before fatal car crash
- Climate change targets could push up household bills by a QUARTER, says Government chief
- Mortgage lending dives 70% to second lowest figure on record as new bank collapses
- Police shoot man dead at 'Omen' cathedral
- Mandelson blamed over 'Britain wants to join euro' claim from EC president
- Mother loses libel case against daughter who wrote book about her abusive childhood
- MORE HEADLINES
- Another scandal at the BBC as Dr Who star John Barrowman apologises for exposing himself during live broadcast
- Arrest... or assault? Judge's disgust after soldier is held down and hit eight times by POLICE
- Home Office 'mole' breaks cover to 'set the record straight' over Tory MP leaks
- Ed Balls sacks £100,000-a-year Baby-P social services boss . . . and says she doesn't deserve a pay-off
- Welcome to Soviet Britain: The towns where half the population relies on the state for a job
- Massive explosion on industrial estate where 'The Office' TV comedy was set
- Boy, 11, killed after being hit TWICE in hit and run smash
- Police shoot man dead after stand-off at 'Omen' cathedral
- The NHS nurse who was paid £100,000 in one year
- The sea turns red as 150 whales are battered to death against rocks in mass stranding off Australian coast
- No.10 hints at review of police powers as Sir Ian Blair's replacement faces calls to quit
- Tacky Christmas! Parents' anger and children's tears at Lapland theme park which turned out to be a muddy field
- Three fire engines turn up to rescue Santa's hat from 'impossible to climb' university spire after student prank
- Pictured: Motorist's lucky escape after teenage yobs drop concrete block on car
- Cheating wife in arranged marriage 'lures her husband to his death in hotel room with her lover'
- MAIL COMMENT: Is the Home Secretary really telling us the full truth?
- Amateur footballer 'killed after fight with opposition players'
- Fairway to heaven: Hit some golfing highs at the loftiest resort around
- Pensioner killed by his own car after thief repeatedly drove over him as he blocked path
- Now Britain is leading the world... in promiscuity
- MOST READ IN DETAIL
Britain appears to be in a very sick position all round. The people of England certainly require an urgent change of government. The prats who lead us are certainly not up to the job.
- William, Bournemouth England, 01/12/2008 16:13