Album Review
It is easy to overrate music made by kids. First and foremost: the "they are pretty good for their age!" factor, which can override critical faculties and make us forgive the sort of artistic decisions we'd normally find boring or annoying in the work of adults. If the young musicians are clearly influenced by things we deem cool, there is a high risk of approving their work simply for affirming our tastes. Most obviously, no one wants to be the creep who begrudges the youthful enthusiasm of people who are clearly having a good time doing cool stuff at a very early age. Nevertheless, if we're being very honest, the music made by children and young teenagers is almost always awful, and the Tiny Masters of Today, despite being signed to an EMI label, are not an exception to the rule.
The Tiny Masters are Ada (13) and Ivan (15), siblings from Brooklyn who have been writing and performing together since their early tweens. They are always joined by an older musician on drums-- in the old days, it was Russell Simins from the Jon Spencer Blues Explosion, but on Skeletons, they are joined by Jackson Pollis, an 18-year-old who is also a member of model Agyness Deyn's band. The fact that these kids apparently require a chaperon is somewhat troubling, but it's probably for the best, as the percussion on the record is solid enough to prop up their understandably limited musical skills. That said, the level of musicianship on the record is adequate, and at least on the same level as countless mediocre punk and indie bands.
That's the root of the problem with the Tiny Masters of Today, though. They are impressive only in comparison to a) other kids their age who have not somehow been encouraged to become a full-time touring band by hipster stage parents, and b) their least-inspired adult contemporaries. At their best, the Tiny Masters provide self-conscious kiddy variations on vaguely arty strains of punk and alt-rock, but there is very little practical use for this music besides causing adults to go, "awww, cute!" The lyrics are predictably banal and laughable, the vocals are uniformly flat and insecure. The melodies are not bad, but they are simplistic and mostly have the irritating cadences of playground chants and jingles. (Truly, much of the album sounds like a series of homemade Mountain Dew ads.)
Though they are kids being kids, there is something very off-putting about how much the Tiny Masters buy into established notions of what punky music made by young teens ought to be like. Many of us were at our most emotional and melodramatic at 13 and 15, but Ivan and Ada seem intent on projecting an image of good-natured brattiness that comes across as false and hollowly nostalgic as a "Dennis the Menace" comic strip. There is an alarming lack of imagination in evidence on Skeletons, and virtually nothing in the way of strong emotion. Every song is charmlessly cutesy, and the most passionate moment on the record comes when Ada slams her square peers on "Abercrombie Zombie". This work may be "pretty good for their age," but that's about it. It does not matter how old the authors may be-- this is very shallow, unengaging music, and it is hard to imagine anyone truly caring about any of these songs.
— Matthew Perpetua, June 17, 2009
Album Player
- Dinosaur Jr.: Farm
- Sunset Rubdown: Dragonslayer
- Regina Spektor: Far
- God Help the Girl: God Help the Girl
- Tortoise: Beacons of Ancestorship
- Gossip: Music For Men
- Bibio: Ambivalence Avenue
- The Lemonheads: Varshons
- Future of the Left: Travels With Myself and Another
- Saint Etienne: Foxbase Alpha / Continental
- Dirty Projectors: Bitte Orca
- Spinnerette: Spinnerette
- Deer Tick: Born on Flag Day
- Noisettes: Wild Young Hearts
- Patterson Hood: Murdering Oscar (and Other Love Songs)
- The Paper Chase: Someday This Could All Be Yours
- Mos Def: The Ecstatic
- Sholi: Sholi
- So Many Dynamos: The Loud Wars
- The Present: World I See / The Way We Are
- The Mars Volta: Octahedron
- Love Is All: Last Choice EP
- Cage: Depart From Me
- Rock Plaza Central: ...At the Moment of Our Most Needing or If Only Th
- EAR PWR: Super Animal Brothers III
- Wilco: Wilco (The Album)
- Isaac Hayes: Hot Buttered Soul
- YaHoWha 13: Magnificence in the Memory
- Drake: So Far Gone
- Zs: Music of the Modern White
- Bibio: Ambivalence Avenue
- Various Artists: A Psychedelic Guide to Monsterism Island
- Ganglians: Ganglians / Monster Head Room
- Hello Seahorse!: Bestia
- Land of Kush: Against the Day
- Tortoise: Beacons of Ancestorship
- The Lemonheads: Varshons
- Alasdair Roberts: Spoils
- So Many Dynamos: The Loud Wars
- The Present: World I See / The Way We Are
Recently
Reviews
- The Mars Volta: Octahedron
- Love Is All: Last Choice EP
- Cage: Depart From Me
- Rock Plaza Central: ...At the Moment of Our Most Needing or If Only Th
- EAR PWR: Super Animal Brothers III
Track Reviews
Reviews
- Wilco: Wilco (The Album)
- Isaac Hayes: Hot Buttered Soul
- YaHoWha 13: Magnificence in the Memory
- Drake: So Far Gone
- Zs: Music of the Modern White
Track Reviews
- The Smith Westerns: "Be My Girl"
- Lupe Fiasco: "Shining Down" [ft. Matthew Santos]
- Drug Rug: "Never Tell"
TV
Features
News
- Mew l The 801 l Bobby Bare Jr. l Whartscape
- T.V. Eye: June 29 - July 4
- Listen to a New Billy Corgan/Sky Saxon Song
- New Release: Yoko Ono Plastic Ono Band: Between...
- Pixies to Celebrate Doolittle on Tour
- Video: Kanye West: "Street Lights"
- MGMT, Karen O Guest on Flaming Lips LP
- Wavves Speaks About Meltdown, Future Plans
- Video: Jay-Z: "D.O.A. (Death of Auto-Tune)"
- New Release: Megafaun: Gather, Form & Fly
Reviews
- Bibio: Ambivalence Avenue
- Various Artists: A Psychedelic Guide to Monsterism Island
- Ganglians: Ganglians / Monster Head Room
- Hello Seahorse!: Bestia
- Land of Kush: Against the Day
Track Reviews
TV
Features
News
- Jackson's Cause of Death Not Yet Determined
- Video: Wilco and Feist Perform "You and I"
- Echo Chamber: Colin Meloy
- Reznor Reveals Rejected Timbaland Remix
- Stars' Amy Millan Preps Second Solo Album
- Blur Reunion Live Album on the Way
- New Release: The Postmarks: Memoirs at the End...
- MGMT to Open for Paul McCartney
- Echo Chamber: Black Francis
- Download a New Fleet Foxes Song
Reviews
- Tortoise: Beacons of Ancestorship
- The Lemonheads: Varshons
- Alasdair Roberts: Spoils
- So Many Dynamos: The Loud Wars
- The Present: World I See / The Way We Are
Track Reviews
News
- Artists React to Michael Jackson's Death
- R.I.P. Michael Jackson
- Benefits: Jeff Tweedy | Robin Pecknold | TVOTR
- Echo Chamber: Morrissey
- Join the Vampire Weekend Tribute Band!
- New Release: Joe Pernice: It Feels So Good...
- Listen: Wale + Peter Bjorn and John
- Thom Yorke, Michael Stipe on Mulcahy Tribute
- Video: Wilco: "You Never Know" (Live on "Conan")
- R.I.P. Seeds Frontman Sky Saxon
Reviews
- Sunset Rubdown: Dragonslayer
- Gossip: Music For Men
- Spinnerette: Spinnerette
- Future of the Left: Travels With Myself and Another
- The Paper Chase: Someday This Could All Be Yours
Track Reviews
Features
News
- Unreleased Jeff Buckley Song in Tearjerker
- Pitchfork on ABC: Kasabian's West Ryder Pauper Lun
- Devendra Banhart Finishes New LP, Leaves XL
- Buy Billy Corgan Lunch!
- New Release: La Roux: La Roux
- Is This the Flaming Lips Album Cover?
- Pitchfork on ABC: God Help the Girl
- The Roots to Debut New Song on "Late Night"
- Chris Knox Leaves Hospital After Stroke
- Jim James to Release George Harrison Tribute
Reviews
- God Help the Girl: God Help the Girl
- Regina Spektor: Far
- Playboy Tre: Liquor Store Mascot
- Noisettes: Wild Young Hearts
- Larry Jon Wilson: Larry Jon Wilson
Track Reviews
- Air France: "GBG Belongs to Us" [ft. Roos]
- The Binary Marketing Show: "Shape of Your Head"
- The Radio Dept.: "David"
News
- Dirty Projectors in Auto Accident
- Common | Reverie Sound Revue | Octopus Project
- Nick Cave and Warren Ellis Score Sex Trade Doc
- Rhino Releases Factory Records Digital Box
- Jay Bennett's Death: Overdose
- Sunny Day Real Estate Reunite!
- Listen to Archived Primavera Sets on WFMU
- Echo Chamber: Dirty Projectors' Dave Longstreth
- Seniors Interview Fiery Furnaces, Bash Wilco
- Arctic Monkeys Unleash Album Art, Dates
Reviews
- Dinosaur Jr.: Farm
- Patterson Hood: Murdering Oscar (and Other Love Songs)
- Sharon Van Etten: Because I Was in Love
- Deer Tick: Born on Flag Day
- Sholi: Sholi
Track Reviews
Features
News
- Crystal Castles Tangle With Security at Sonar
- Rhino Releases Los Angeles Nuggets Box Set
- Echo Chamber: Death Cab's Chris Walla
- Watch Jack White's New Band Live Right Now!
- A Sunny Day in Glasgow Ready Sophomore LP
- T.V. Eye: June 22-28
- Video: Clipse [ft. Kanye]: "Kinda Like a Big Deal"
- Radiohead/Wilco/Marr Supergroup LP Details
- Wu-Tang Clan Brings Us Chamber Music
- TVOTR's Malone Signs to Anti- for Solo Project