SUBSCRIBE TO NEW SCIENTIST

Opinion

Feeds

Home |Opinion | Opinion

Malcolm Gladwell's miscellany of myths

  • Book information
  • What the Dog Saw by Malcolm Gladwell
  • Published by: Allen Lane/Little, Brown
  • Price: £20/$27.99

THOUGH it may seem gratuitous to publish a collection of essays that have already appeared in magazines or journals, in Malcolm Gladwell's case it is justified because his writing and storytelling abilities are so good.

The articles in What the Dog Saw are from The New Yorker, where Gladwell is a staff writer, and the style will be familiar to those who have read his previous books: insightful, relentless and mischievous. Whether he's disassembling the "science" of criminal profiling, exploding the myth that creativity is an artefact of youth, or exposing the conceit of those who claim the 9/11 attacks were predictable from intelligence reports, he has a knack for teasing out the complexities behind the obvious, and the fun in the seemingly mundane. His greatest asset is his curiosity, and there are lessons in his "leave no stone unturned" approach for anyone of a rationalist bent.

Issue 2733 of New Scientist magazine
  • Subscribe to New Scientist and you'll get:
  • New Scientist magazine delivered to your door
  • Unlimited access to all New Scientist online content -
    a benefit only available to subscribers
  • Great savings from the normal price
  • Subscribe now!

If you would like to reuse any content from New Scientist, either in print or online, please contact the syndication department first for permission. New Scientist does not own rights to photos, but there are a variety of licensing options available for use of articles and graphics we own the copyright to.

Have your say
Comments 1 | 2

Gladwell Is A Hack

Sat Nov 07 12:18:46 GMT 2009 by James

The only knack Malcolm Gladwell has is for taking bogus posits and spinning them into something halfway believable and having everyone hold him up as a genius

Gladwell Is A Hack

Sat Nov 07 16:17:52 GMT 2009 by Anthony

Evidence? He wrote a book... You wrote a sentence....

Gladwell Is A Hack

Sun Nov 08 07:34:35 GMT 2009 by Polemos
http://eschatopedia.webs.com/electronandproton.htm

The radius (the Compton wavelength) of a particle is inversely proportional to the particle's mass:

"The Compton wavelength, λ, of a particle is given by λ = h/mc, where h is the Planck constant, m is the particle's rest mass, and c is the speed of light." [Source]

That is why as the electron's mass decreases, its size increases. The size of the proton, on the contrary, decreases (because its mass increases). Eventually, the size of the electron (the basic localization plus the tail) expands to the size of the universe, while the radius of the proton contracts to the Schwartzchild radius corresponding to the proton mass:

"4.5 The ultimate fate of the Universe

In Section 3 we saw that at a time n = N (where n is the time in atomic time units, and N is the baryon number of the Universe), the evolution of the Omega Universe reaches a state at which the Planck length is equal to the Compton wavelength of the proton, and the Planck mass is equal to the proton mass. In other words, the scale factor of the Universe has evolved to the point where the radius of the proton exceeds the Schwartzchild radius corresponding to the proton mass. At this point the Universe effectively comes to an end as all protons simultaneously collapse into micro Black Holes." [Booth, Robin ♦ Machian General Relativity ♦ page 16]

The size of a Planckian black hole calculated by Craig Hogan is 10−16 m (see End of Locality).

The radius (the Compton wavelength) of a free proton (+R) is 2.10553 × 10−16 m [Hofstadter, R. ♦ Reviews of Modern Physics, volume 28, p. 213 (1956)]. [Source]

This means that the universe's protons are on the brink of a black-hole collapse.

Read more: http://eschatopedia.webs.com/electronandproton.htm

Gladwell Is A Hack

Sun Nov 08 08:00:33 GMT 2009 by Sebastian

Oh, Polemos! Give it a rest!

Gladwell Is A Hack

Sun Nov 08 11:43:23 GMT 2009 by Buckshot

Here is a quote from a recent Malcolm Gladwell interview:

"....Outliers is a lot like Blink and Tipping Point. They are all attempts to make us think about the world a little differently."

Try browsing his web site Gladwell.com.

Gladwell Is A Hack

Sat Nov 07 23:56:22 GMT 2009 by DH

Bogus posits, really? I suppose some people need to cling to myth as a refuge from reality.

On the other hand, thanks NS for the heads up, because the three issues raised in the review are among my biggest bugbears. Criminal profiling has bounced back from the Richard Jewell fiasco stronger than ever. The 9-11 conceit is just a replay of the "Roosevelt knew about Pearl Harbor" myth. The youth-creativity nonsense does not make sense on any level and I have always wondered how this misconception arose.

Ok

Sat Nov 07 13:55:19 GMT 2009 by WRQ9

it's a good thing there are fewer ideas than there are people or a consensus might never occur on anything.

Ok

Sat Nov 07 16:50:52 GMT 2009 by Eric M. Jones
http://www.PerihelionDesign.com

A good claim could be made that there are far more ideas than people. Polemos will back me up on this.

Thanksgiving Gift. . .

Sat Nov 07 15:01:12 GMT 2009 by lisa
http://www.coolforsale.com

In order to meet the Thanksgiving holiday, this site hereby releaseThanksgiving gift, that is, gift, our web site is http://www.coolforsale.com nike air max jordan shoes, coach,gucci,lv,dg,ed hardy handbags, Polo/Ed Hardy/Lacoste/Ca/A&F; ,T-shirt welcome new and old customers come to order.

Thanksgiving Gift. . .

Sat Nov 07 20:17:20 GMT 2009 by Rose

HUH??

Comments 1 | 2

All comments should respect the New Scientist House Rules. If you think a particular comment breaks these rules then please use the "Report" link in that comment to report it to us.

If you are having a technical problem posting a comment, please contact technical support.

ADVERTISEMENT

Why did our species survive the Neanderthals?

10:00 08 November 2009

According to Clive Finlayson in The Humans Who Went Extinct, we were just lucky

The music of Life on EarthAudio Speaker

10:00 07 November 2009

Edward Williams's music for Life on Earth is as atmospheric and innovative as the classic 1979 David Attenborough TV series it was composed for

Nicky Clayton: Dancing with Darwin

12:26 05 November 2009

The bird cognition expert has worked with the Rambert Dance Company on its new evolution-inspired show, now on tour in the UK

Terry Pratchett: Fighting to keep the fantasy alive

10:44 04 November 2009

The prolific author discusses tinkering with science, his battle with Alzheimer's, and the odds of escaping from a crab bucket

Latest news

Spy-in-the-cab could improve teenage driving

12:00 08 November 2009

Novice drivers are responsible for a disproportionate number of accidents – now an in-car warning system has cut incidents of reckless driving by half

Evidence recovered from dirty DNA samples

11:00 08 November 2009

Contaminated DNA that would normally be written off can now provide evidence, thanks to amplification enzymes that tolerate pollution

Why did our species survive the Neanderthals?

10:00 08 November 2009

According to Clive Finlayson in The Humans Who Went Extinct, we were just lucky

The music of Life on EarthAudio Speaker

10:00 07 November 2009

Edward Williams's music for Life on Earth is as atmospheric and innovative as the classic 1979 David Attenborough TV series it was composed for

TWITTER

New Scientist is on Twitter

Get the latest from New Scientist: sign up to our Twitter feed

ADVERTISEMENT

Partners

We are partnered with Approved Index. Visit the site to get free quotes from website designers and a range of web, IT and marketing services in the UK.

Login for full access