Subscribe to New Scientist

Opinion

Feeds
Comments 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7

Orcs And Neandertals

Mon Nov 09 10:11:34 GMT 2009 by ugh

Orcs resemble Neandertals, are evil and eat human children and talk with a deep inhuman voice...

Is that our racial memory of a terrible genocidal war we had when colonizing Europe, where no atrocity was spared to the enemy and by the enemy? Was "Orc" the way we used to call them? That makes a nice story.

Orcs And Neandertals

Mon Nov 09 10:25:55 GMT 2009 by Ming

Looking to read ur book ; Neanderthal the orcs eat children.

And i thought i was off topic, our friends are gone and more friends will go hopefully more friends will come :)

Orcs And Neandertals

Mon Nov 09 10:40:08 GMT 2009 by ugh

I am looking to have some friends for dinner. Hannibal the Cannibal. :)

They Still Exist

Mon Nov 09 11:22:56 GMT 2009 by Bill

I'm sorry to say but unfortunately for us the Neanderthals still exist, only now instead of wearing skins and killing their food with clubs and spears the 21st century versions wear Hoodies and kick innocent people to death.

You can take the Neanderthal out of the cave but you can't take the cave out of the modern day throwbacks. Some genes seem to persist.

Enough Of The Out Of Africa Dogma

Mon Nov 09 13:05:20 GMT 2009 by Bert

It's time to leave the Out Of Africa theory.

A deluge of recent data suggests it.

Seems to me, it's still around owing more to political correctness than hard science.

Enough Of The Out Of Africa Dogma

Mon Nov 09 15:00:32 GMT 2009 by Paul

I thought it was more the whole mitochondrial dna thing than political correctness, though it's interesting to see the contradicting evidence coming out lately I agree

Enough Of The Out Of Africa Dogma

Tue Nov 10 02:34:12 GMT 2009 by Liza

"it's still around owing more to political correctness than hard science."

Political correctness? Would you say a theory that states modern humans thrived by supplanting and probably exterminating other humans is PC? To me, the multiregional hypothesis is the PC fairy tale story- we all evolved together, contributions from all populations of humans across the globe, no genocides or supremacy involved. A pity it's not true.

Enough Of The Out Of Africa Dogma

Wed Nov 11 20:43:45 GMT 2009 by Jeremy

Portraying our ancestors as evil as they turned white and entered Europe is PC. Also portraying the roots of "humanity" to be African is PC.

We did all evolve together, different species of hominid living at the same times, although not interbreeding much and some genetic offshoots were dead-end. In fact they were all dead-end except our direct ancestors, and their direct ancestors. We may have Neanderthal genes in us; it's not known for sure yet.

Given enough time we will be a separate species too. Our descendants will change enough over many generations that someday they can look back and declare us a different species because they'll be so different from the way we are now. That's the record of humanity. Evolution continues apace in us more than, say, in alligators that haven't changed much over millions of years.

There's no guarantee we'll get smarter and more desirable as a species, either. In fact social evolution is favoring the brutish degenerates. There's evidence that when proto-chimps and proto-humans split, the proto-chimps were not knuckle-walkers like they are now---they evolved into being that way.

Planet of the Apes, anyone?

Climate Change

Mon Nov 09 13:26:48 GMT 2009 by Simon

Climate has a habit of changing. 18,000 years ago the ocean was 390 feet lower. Back even further in Neanderthal times the climate was of course affected by all the CO2 emitted by the massive industrialisation of homo sapiens. The slum dwelling neanderthals died out due to climate change. Too bad they had no green taxes to change the climate. Paying tax changes the weather, you know.

Disease Vector Maybe?

Mon Nov 09 15:01:30 GMT 2009 by Rob Walker

Many native Americans were wiped out by European diseases for which they had no immmunity.

Possibly the Neandertalers were hit by this also, and fell below the survivability line

This comment breached our terms of use and has been removed.

Comments 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7

All comments should respect the New Scientist House Rules. If you think a particular comment breaks these rules then please use the "Report" link in that comment to report it to us.

If you are having a technical problem posting a comment, please contact technical support.

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest news articles

Propelled by light: the promise and perils of solar sailing

21:30 11 November 2009

Despite earlier failures, the Planetary Society is gearing up to test another solar sail in space in a year – executive director Louis Friedman explains why

Less loud sounds can still damage ears

22:00 11 November 2009

If the results in mice translate to humans, the laws that determine the noises workers can be exposed to may need to change

Today on New Scientist: 11 November 2009

18:00 11 November 2009

Today's stories on newscientist.com, at a glance, including: what the LHC is really looking for, how a mini ice age took hold of Europe in months, and how to get a club-winged manakin excited

Suite of chatterbox genes discovered

18:00 11 November 2009

A set of 116 genes influenced by Foxp2 could have coevolved to give humans language

ADVERTISEMENT

Partners

We are partnered with Approved Index. Visit the site to get free quotes from website designers and a range of web, IT and marketing services in the UK.

Login for full access