Editorial: Uh-oh, more emotions to worry about
CAN you name the six basic emotions? Take a straw poll of your friends and we guarantee that you will find no consensus. Yet psychologists are unequivocal: joy, sadness, anger, fear, surprise and disgust. These are the Big Six, quite literally, the in-your-face emotions - the ones that everyone the world over exhibits with the same dramatic and characteristic facial expressions. They have been the subjects of intense research for over half a century, not least because of the role they have played in our survival as a species.
Times have changed, though. Our ancestors may have had daily need of fear to flee predators, anger to conquer foes and disgust to avoid diseases, but we live in a more subtle world in which other emotions have come to the fore. There are many contenders. Avarice, embarrassment, boredom, depression, jealousy and love, for example, might epitomise the modern age. Yet some more obscure emotions may be increasingly relevant today. Here we explore five of them, any one of which could make a case to be promoted to a place alongside the Big Six.
ELEVATION
The uplifting emotion
"Let it be said by our children's children that when we were tested we refused to let this journey end, that we did not turn back nor did we falter; and with eyes fixed on the horizon and God's grace upon us, we carried forth that great gift of freedom and delivered it safely to future generations."
In the midst of last year's economic turmoil President Barack Obama's inauguration speech was powerful, inspiring stuff. Some of his supporters, hanging on his every word, will have had tears in their eyes, a tingling sensation on the back of their necks and a warm feeling in their chest as though it was opening up to let love and hope flood out. This feeling is what Jonathan Haidt at the University of Virginia, Charlottesville, has labelled "elevation".
Elevation seems to be a universal feeling. Although not yet studied in modern-day pre-literate societies, it has been documented in people from Japan, India, the US and the Palestinian territories. That puts it in the same league as the Big Six. But to be considered as a basic emotion it should also have a purpose. If emotions are to fulfil their role as survival aids, they must motivate activities that help us thrive. So what is elevation for? Originally Haidt thought that it makes us nobler towards others. But when he asked volunteers to watch either an uplifting episode of Oprah or a non-uplifting scene from the sitcom Seinfeld, and then gave them a chance to help a stranger, there was no difference in behaviour between the two groups.
Haidt's next idea was born of the choked feelings that people often report when they describe experiencing elevation. This hints that the vagus nerve is involved because it is responsible for stimulating the throat and neck muscles. Activation of the vagus nerve is also linked to the release of a hormone called oxytocin, which generates warm, calm feelings - just the sort associated with elevation. Could oxytocin be the key? The inspiration for how to test this idea came from his student, Jennifer Silvers, who pointed out that oxytocin makes nursing mothers release milk.
So in a second round of experiments, Haidt and Silvers showed the same videos to breastfeeding mothers. They found that after watching Oprah mothers were more likely to leak milk into a nursing pad. They also spent more time nursing and hugging their babies than the mothers who watched the Seinfeld video (Emotion, vol 8, p 291). "Oxytocin doesn't make people go out and give money to charity, it doesn't make people help strangers jump-start their cars, it makes them want to touch, hug and be more open and trusting with each other," says Haidt.
So elevation has a physiological component and motivational one too. However, unlike the Big Six emotions, it does not have an obvious characteristic facial expression, which may explain why it has slipped under the research radar for so long. If you appreciate the context, you may be able to detect a slight softening of the features, says Haidt. Sometimes the eyebrows are raised as if the person is sad.
Elevation is also relatively rare. People typically experience it less than once a week, although there are wide individual differences. Where it does score, though, is in being highly significant. "If you ask people to remember their most cherished experiences of their whole life, elevatory moments are likely to feature in their top five," says Haidt. What's more, if we can harness elevation to build trust, it could have particular relevance in the modern world for strengthening or repairing personal relationships. Haidt envisages a time, for example, when marital therapists might try to induce it so as to enhance the effectiveness of couples' counselling sessions.
- Like what you've just read?
- Don't miss out on the latest content from New Scientist.
- Get New Scientist magazine delivered to your door, plus unlimited access to the entire content of New Scientist online.
- Subscribe now and save
If you would like to reuse any content from New Scientist, either in print or online, please contact the syndication department first for permission. New Scientist does not own rights to photos, but there are a variety of licensing options available for use of articles and graphics we own the copyright to.
Have your say
Oh not again: the annoyance of reading another space filling coffee table magazine article in your expensive NS subscription.
This comment breached our terms of use and has been removed.
This comment breached our terms of use and has been removed.
I find NS to be a good indicator of the kinds of issues important to the current issue most important to the current academic elites: increasing the power of government; and to their pseudointellectual pawns: dope smoking, sex, etc. One of the most powerful forces being used to move society from modernism to postmodernism is emotion. Understanding emotion, and how it is being emphasized and enhanced in order to direct the populace, is a worthwile topic of attention. As intellectualism led to modernism and then humanism, emotionalism is now leading society to postmodernism and posthumanism.
"oh Not Again"
Fri Jan 15 14:16:35 GMT 2010 by Rupre
http://freetubetv.net
Interesting theory, but postmodern is now it's not an actual time period
Here's One From Portugal, The Land Of Fado
Wed Jan 13 18:41:36 GMT 2010 by Carla Francisco
http://carlafrancisco.blogspot.com
Saudade (Portuguese): a deep and dramatic sense of longing for someone or something (a favourite food, your country, the "good old times"...)
Here's One From Portugal, The Land Of Fado
Wed Jan 13 20:04:48 GMT 2010 by Miguel
http://ruisilva.com
same as... nostalgia?
Nostalgia is too exclusive; "yearning" is a better word
Nostalgia alone doesn't cut it because it is a mix of different emotions and attitudes.
It drives some to brave the harshest conditions to get over the hurdle that's keeping them away from their home and family.
It also drives others to give it all up exactly because they can't stand the parting anymore.
It drives artists to paint beautiful compositions of home when they're away, and poets to sing the virtues of the people, when they're not there.
To use a "in vogue" sentence: It's complicated.
I would dare state it's a culturally inherited emotion: you have to be Portuguese to understand it
Or Brazilian!
My 1 cent: You don't feel nostalgia for your gf that is away in a 15 days trip. You feel "saudades". But is different from missing her.
Sounds like "hiraeth" to me. It's the welsh word for the same thing.
More Emotions
Wed Jan 13 18:58:19 GMT 2010 by Elsa
http://www.elsas-word-story-image-idea-music-emporium.com/good-caring.html
This is the second time I've heard of the emotion, elevation - and yet I have felt it often. Great that you included that emotion, started with it even.
Other emotions are coming to mind: empathy, compassion, sympathy - each different. Then there is awe - which may be related to elevation, but need not be.
And then there is pity.
And how about ambivalence - or is that not quite an emotion?
Ambivalence? I would say it does not qualify as an emotion in the context of the article; more, in my opinion, it is a lack/absence of an emotion i.e. "I really don't care one way or the other".
All comments should respect the New Scientist House Rules. If you think a particular comment breaks these rules then please use the "Report" link in that comment to report it to us.
If you are having a technical problem posting a comment, please contact technical support.