Product Reviews

TiVo HD XL

TiVo HD XL DVR Proves Bigger Is Sometimes Better
$600  •  tivo.com
8 out of 10

 

TiVo HD XL DVR Proves Bigger Is Sometimes Better

Everything's getting tiny. The once sexy V-8 engine is now an automotive pariah while the Smart Car gets all the chicks; HD video cameras are now damn near Twinkie-size, and we'll probably be implanting the next-generation iPod in our molars.

But at least one company isn't succumbing to all this smaller-is-better madness: TiVo just announced the TiVo HD XL. Stuffed like a Cornish hen with a terabyte hard drive, it's the highest capacity DVR available with room for 150 hours of HD content. That's, like, every Olympic event you actually care about plus all 60 episodes of The Wire. It's an entire season of Sunday Night Football with more than enough space for your Food Network-obsessed roommate to go balls-out on Batali.

WIRED Western Digital hard drive is nearly silent. THX-certified audio and video (finally). Say goodbye to the ugly stick — the XL gets the same slick programmable remote as the Series 3. TiVo-easy, as expected, with the company's ever expanding catalog of downloadable videos (YouTube!).

TIRED Remote collects more greasy fingerprints than a secondhand sex-bot. Annoying info screen hovers over the picture a few seconds too long with each channel change. Cutesy TiVo noises are a little grating, and your only other option is to turn all the sound effects off. We noticed an increase in video artifacts when recording off both tuners simultaneously.  In San Francisco, at least, you have to deal with Satan Comcast to get service. $600 plus the $20 $12.95 monthly fee is a lot of cheddar.

  • Video Components: DVRs
  • Manufacturer: TiVo
  • Price: $600
Reddit Digg

Pricing

Shop At Price In Stock? Seller Rating VeriSign Secured
Vanns.com $399.88 Yes 5.00
CompUSA $399.99 Yes 4.47 VeriSign Secured
HIDEF Lifestyle $599.99 Yes 0.00 VeriSign Secured
TigerDirect $399.99 Yes 4.68 VeriSign Secured
Amazon.com $499.99 Yes 0.00 VeriSign Secured
HD XL 150-Hour Digital Video Recorder prices from PriceGrabber.com

Editors' Ratings — what do they mean?

  • Metaphysical product perfection
  • Nearly flawless — buy it now
  • Excellent, with room to kibitz
  • Very good, but not quite great
  • A solid product with some issues
  • Recommended with reservations
  • Downsides outweigh upsides
  • Serious flaws, proceed with caution
  • Just barely functional — don't buy it
  • A complete failure in every way

Services