Wind power in the United Kingdom

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
United Kingdom
energy related articles
Government energy policy
Energy use and conservation
Nuclear power
Solar power
Wind power
Energy efficiency in housing
Climate Change Programme
Other UK energy articles
UK installed wind power capacity 1990-2010
Burbo Bank Offshore Wind Farm.

As of January 2010, the installed capacity of wind power in the United Kingdom was over 4 gigawatts (GW). Wind power is the second largest source of renewable energy in the UK after biomass. Over 1 GW of new wind power capacity was brought online during 2009, 800 MW onshore and 285 MW offshore (1 GW = 1000 MW). RenewableUK estimates that installed capacity will pass the 5 and 6 GW marks during 2010. The milestone of 1 GW of installed offshore capacity was reached in April 2010, with the opening of the Gunfleet Sands and Robin Rigg wind farms.[1]

As of 1 August 2010, there were 264 operational wind farms in the UK, with 2,908 turbines and 4,580 MW of installed capacity. A further 2,450 MW worth of schemes are currently under construction, while another 6,494 MW have planning consent and some 9,844 MW are in planning awaiting approval.[2] In 2010, National Grid plc forecast the cumulative nameplate capacity of windfarms connected to the transmission network to be 1.6 GW, and forecast this to rise significantly over the next 10 years, potentially to 32GW.[3]

In 2007, approximately 1.5% of UK electricity was generated by wind power (with a total of around 4.5% of UK electricity coming from all renewable sources.[4]) This is expected to rise dramatically in coming years, as a result of the British government's energy policy strongly supporting new renewable energy generating capacity. In the short to medium term, the bulk of this new capacity is expected to be provided by onshore and offshore wind power.

In 2007 the UK Government agreed to an overall European Union target of generating 20% of EU’s energy supply from renewable sources by 2020. Each EU member state was given its own allocated target; for the UK it is 15%. This was formalised in January 2009 with the passage of the EU Renewables Directive. As renewable heat and fuel production in the UK are at extremely low bases, RenewableUK estimates that this will require 35–40% of the UK’s electricity to be generated from renewable sources by that date,[5] to be met largely by 33–35 GW of installed wind capacity.

In December 2007, the Government announced plans for a massive expansion of wind energy in the UK, by conducting a Strategic Environmental Assessment of up to 25 GW worth of wind farm offshore sites in preparation for a new round of development. These proposed sites are in addition to the 8 GW worth of sites already awarded in the 2 earlier rounds of site allocations, Round 1 in 2001 and Round 2 in 2003. Taken together it is estimated that this would result in the construction of over 7,000 offshore wind turbines.[6]

Contents

[edit] Offshore wind farms

The United Kingdom became the world leader of offshore wind power generation in October 2008 when it overtook Denmark.[7] Currently it has 1,041 MW of operational nameplate capacity, with a further 1,452 MW in construction.[8] The UK has been estimated to have over a third of Europe's total offshore wind resource, which is equivalent to three times the electricity needs of the nation at current rates of electricity consumption. (In 2010 peak winter demand was 59.3 GW,[9] in summer it drops to about 45 GW). One estimate calculates that wind turbines in one third of UK waters shallower than 25 metres (82 ft) would, on average, generate 40 GW; turbines in one third of the waters between 25 metres (82 ft) and 50 metres (164 ft) depth would on average generate a further 80 GW, i.e. 120 GW in total).[10]. An estimate of the theoretical maximum potential of the UK's offshore wind resource in all waters to 700 metres (2,300 ft) depth gives the average power as 2200 GW.[11]

The first developments in UK offshore wind power came about through the now discontinued Non-Fossil Fuel Obligation (NFFO), leading to two wind farms, Blyth Offshore and Gunfleet sands.[12] The NFFO was introduced as part of the Electricity Act 1989 and obliged UK electricity supply companies to secure specified amounts of electricity from non-fossil sources,[13] which provided the initial spur for the commercial development of renewable energy in the UK.

The UK will require 7,500 offshore turbines by 2020 to meet EU targets.[14]

[edit] Round 1

In 1998 the British Wind Energy Association (now RenewableUK) began discussions with the government to draw up formal procedures for negotiating with the Crown Estate, the owner of almost all the UK coastline out to distance of 12 nautical miles (22.2 km). The result was a set of guidelines published in 1999, and a huge increase in the number of applications submitted. Eighteen of the applications were granted permission to proceed in April 2001, in what has become known as round one of UK offshore wind development.

The first of the round one projects completed, and the first large scale offshore wind farm in the UK, North Hoyle, was commissioned in December 2003. The second, Scroby Sands, was completed one year later in December 2004, followed by the 90 MW Kentish Flats in 2005. The fourth, Barrow Offshore, with 30 turbines, finished construction in July 2006. Seven of the remaining projects have received consent from the planning authorities, while the remaining four are still awaiting consent, including the Shell Flat site off the coast of Lancashire, which has since been withdrawn.

[edit] Round 2

Lessons learnt from round one, particularly the difficulty in getting planning consent for offshore wind farms, together with the increasing pressure to reduce CO2 emissions, prompted the Department of Trade and Industry (DTI) to develop a strategic framework for the offshore wind industry. The result, known as Round 2, was announced in December 2003 with 15 projects with a combined capacity of 7.2 GW. By far the largest of these are the 1 GW London Array and the 1.2 GW Triton Knoll.[15]

[edit] Round 1 and 2 Extensions

In May 2010 the Crown Estate gave approval for seven Round 1 and 2 sites to be extended creating an additional 2 GW of offshore wind capacity.[16] Each wind farm extension will require a complete new planning application including an Environmental Impact Assessment and full consultation. The sites are:[17]

[edit] Round 3

Following on from the Offshore wind SEA announced by the Government in December 2007, the Crown Estate launched a third round of site allocations in June 2008. Round 3 is envisaged on a much bigger scale than either of its predecessors – combined, Rounds 1 and 2 allocated 8 GW of sites, while Round 3 alone could identify up to 25 GW.

The Crown Estate proposed 9 offshore zones, within which a number of individual wind farms would be situated. It ran a competitive tender process to award leases to consortia of potential developers. The bidding closed in March 2009 with over 40 applications from companies and consortia and multiple tenders for each zone. On 8 January 2010 the successful bidders were announced.

Following the allocation of zones, individual planning applications still have to be sought by developers. These are unlikely to be completed before 2012 and as such the first Round 3 projects are not expected to begin generating electricity before 2015.

[edit] Round 3 consortia

During the bidding process, there was considerable speculation over which companies had bid for the zones. The Crown Estate did not make the list public and most of the consortia also remained silent. The successful bidders for each zone were eventually announced as follows:[18]

Round 3 Windfarms
Zone[19] Zone Name Potential
Power (GW)
Developer Notes
1 Moray Firth 1.3 Moray Offshore Renewables Ltd formed from EDP Renováveis and SeaEnergy Renewables Ltd (SERL)
2 Firth of Forth 3.5 Seagreen Wind Energy Ltd partnership between SSE Renewables and Fluor Ltd
3 Dogger Bank 9 Forewind a consortium made up of SSE Renewables, RWE npower, Statkraft and Statoil.
If built this would be the world's largest offshore wind farm.
4 Hornsea 4 Mainstream Renewable Power
Siemens Financial Services
5 Norfolk Bank[20] 7.2 ScottishPower Renewables
Vattenfall AB
Known as the East Anglia Array
6 Southern Array[20] 0.6 E.ON formerly "Hastings"
7 West of Isle of Wight 0.9 Eneco Known as the Eneco Wind Park
8 Bristol Channel 1.5 RWE npower Known as the Atlantic Array
9 Irish Sea 4.2 Centrica
Total 32.2

[edit] Scottish offshore

In addition to the 25 GW scoped under the Round 3 SEA, the Scottish Government and the Crown Estate have also called for bids on potential sites within Scottish territorial waters. These were originally considered as too deep to provide viable sites, however 17 companies submitted tenders and the Crown Estate has signed ‘exclusivity agreements with 9 companies for 6 GW worth of sites.[21] An SEA will still have to be carried out on these sites before planning permissions are granted. The sites are:

Windfarms in Scottish Waters
Zone[22] Farm Power (MW) Developer Notes
1 Solway Firth 300 E.ON Climate & Renewables UK Develpoments
2 Wigtown Bay 280 DONG Wind (UK)
3 Kintyre 378 Airtricity Holdings (UK) Ltd
4 Islay 680 Airtricity Holdings (UK) Ltd
5 Argyll Array 1500 Scottish Power Renewables
6 Beatrice 920 Airtricity Holdings (UK) Ltd
SeaEnergy Renewables Ltd
7 Inch Cape 905 Npower Renewables Ltd
SeaEnergy Renewables Ltd
8 Neart na Gaoithe 360 Mainstream Renewable Power Ltd
9 Forth Array 415 Fred. Olsen Renewables Ltd
Bell Rock Airtricity Holdings (UK) Ltd
Fluor Ltd
Development halted due to radar services in the area[23]
Total 5,738

[edit] List of built and proposed offshore wind farms

UK Offshore Windfarms[8][24]
Farm Completed Power (MW) No. Turbines Notes Round
Blyth Offshore December 2000 4 2 Evaluation project NFFO
North Hoyle December 2003 60 30 The UK's first major offshore wind farm 1
Scroby Sands December 2004 60 30 1
Kentish Flats December 2005 90 30 1
Barrow Offshore Wind May 2006 90 30 1
Burbo Bank October 2007 90 25 1
Beatrice August 2007 10 2 Deep water evaluation project.[25]
Lynn and Inner Dowsing October 2008[7] 194 54 1
Rhyl Flats December 2009 90 25 Officially inaugurated 2 December 2009[26] 1
Gunfleet Sands I April 2010 108 30 Officially inaugurated 16 June 2010 [27] 1
Gunfleet Sands II April 2010 64 18 As above 2
Robin RiggSolway Firth April 2010 180 60 The UK's largest operational offshore wind farm.[28] 1
Greater Gabbard 504 140 Approved. Under construction[29] 2
Ormonde 150 30 Approved. Under construction[30] 1
Sheringham Shoal 315 88 Approved. Under construction[31] 2
Thanet 300 100 Approved. Under construction[32] 2
Walney I & II 367 102 Approved. Phase I under construction[33] 2
Gwynt y Môr 576 160 Consent granted December 2008. Construction to begin in 2011[34] 2
Lincs 270 75 Consent granted January 2007. Construction to begin in 2010[35] 2
London Array 1,000 341 Consent granted December 2006.[36] Offshore construction to begin in 2011[37] 2
Teesside/Redcar 90 30 Consent granted September 2007.[38] Construction to begin in 2010[39] 1
West of Duddon Sands 500 160 Consent granted September 2008.[40] 2
Docking Shoal ~500 83 to 177 Planning application submitted in December 2008[41] 2
Dudgeon up to 560 up to 168 Planning application submitted in December 2009[42] 2
Humber Gateway 300 42 to 83 Planning in progress[43] 2
Race Bank 620 88 to 206 Planning application submitted in January 2009[44] 2
Westermost Rough 234 65 Planning application submitted in November 2009[45] 2
Triton Knoll 1,200 240 Planning stage, pending EIA[46] 2
Atlantic Array 1,500 350 Planning stage, pending SEA, construction 2013-2018[47] 3
Cromer 108 30 Withdrawn after approval[8]
Scarweather Sands 108 30 Withdrawn after approval[8]
Shell Flat 180 90 Withdrawn after resubmission[48]

[edit] Onshore wind farms

The Ardrossan Wind Farm in North Ayrshire, Scotland
The wind turbine at Greenpark, Reading, Berkshire

The first windfarms in the UK were built onshore, and they currently generate more power than the offshore farms. Gaining planning permission for onshore wind farms is proving difficult, with many schemes stalled in the planning system, and a high rate of refusal.[49] The RenewableUK (formerly BWEA) figures show that there are approximately 7,000 MW worth of onshore schemes waiting for planning permission. On average a wind farm planning application takes 2 years to be considered by a local authority, with an approval rate of 40%. This compares extremely unfavourably with other types of major applications, such as housing, retail outlets and roads, 70% of which are decided within the 13-16 week statutory deadline; for wind farms the rate is just 6%.

Approximately half of all wind farm planning applications, over 4 GW worth of schemes, have objections from airports and traffic control on account of their impact on radar. In 2008 NATS en Route, the BWEA, the Ministry of Defence and other Government departments signed a Memorandum of Understanding seeking to establish a mechanism for resolving objections and funding for more technical research.

In the year to 31 March 2005, onshore wind farms, according to Ofgem, produced 1,734 gigawatt-hours (GW·h), an average of 198 MW, but this is expected to rise to 2,500 GW·h (an average of 285 MW) in the following year, so there is considerable scope for further growth (16,600 MW peak capacity had been installed in Germany by 2004).[50]

According to DTI figures onshore wind farms in the UK generated 2,501 GW·h in 2005, while offshore farms generated 403 GW·h. This compares to a total electricity demand of 407,265 GW·h for the same year, meaning that the combined onshore and offshore contribution to UK electricity generation was 0.71%. In 2006, onshore wind farms generated 3,574 GW·h, while offshore farms generated 651 GW·h. In 2007 wind farms generated 4,491 GW·h (onshore) and 783 GW·h (offshore), while in 2008 generation had risen to 5,792 GW h (onshore) and 1,305 GW·h (offshore). As total demand had fallen to 399,619 GW·h, the combined contribution of onshore and offshore wind in 2008 was 1.78%.[51] In 2007 the planning permission problem was exacerbated by a shortage of spare parts for certain models of generator, which put some turbines out of action for over six months, triggering clauses in planning consents requiring removal of the non-functional turbines.[52]

[edit] List of the largest operational and proposed onshore wind farms

UK Onshore Windfarms
Wind Farm County Country Turbine model Power (MW)
each Turbine
No. of Turbines Total capacity
(MW)
Online Notes
Black Law Phase I & II South Lanarkshire Scotland Siemens SWT-2.3 2.3 54 124 September 2005 Extended September 2006
Braes of Doune Stirling Scotland Vestas V80 2 36 72 February 2007
Farr Wind Farm Highland Scotland Bonus B2300 2.3 40 92 May 2006
Hadyard Hill Wind Farm South Ayrshire Scotland Bonus B2300 2.5 52 120 March 2006
Scout Moor Wind Farm Lancashire England Nordex N80 2.5 26 65 September 2008 Largest onshore farm in England
Whitelee Wind Farm East Renfrewshire Scotland Siemens SWT-2.3 2.3 140 322 November 2008 2nd largest onshore farm in Europe, largest in the UK
Arecleoch South Ayrshire Scotland 2 60 120 Under construction[53]
Crystal Rig 2 (extension) Scottish Borders Scotland 2.3 51 117.3 Under construction[54]
Beinn Mhor (Muaithaebhal) Western Isles Scotland 3.6 33 118 Consent granted January 2010[55]
Whitelee Phase II extension East Renfrewshire Scotland 3.6 39 140 Consent granted December 2009[56]
Berry Burn Moray Scotland 3.7 29 78.3 Consent granted August 2009[57]
Whitelee Phase I extension East Renfrewshire Scotland 3.6 36 129.6 Consent granted May 2009[56]
Clyde Wind Farm South Lanarkshire Scotland 2.3 152 349.6 Consent granted July 2008[58]

[edit] The renewables obligation

Through the Renewables Obligation, British electricity suppliers are now required by law to provide a proportion of their sales from renewable sources such as wind power or pay a penalty fee. The supplier then receives a Renewables Obligation Certificate (ROC) for each MWh of electricity they have purchased. The Energy Act 2008 introduced banded ROCs for different technologies from April 2009. Onshore wind continues to receive 1 ROC per MWh, however offshore wind now receives 1.5 ROCs, while small wind systems under 50 kW currently receive 2 ROCs. Wind energy receives approximately one third of the total revenue generated by the RO. The ROCs are the principal form of support for UK wind power, providing around half of the revenue from wind generation.[59]

[edit] Capacity factor and related issues

Because the level at which a wind farm operates is determined by the wind speed at any particular time, capacity factor bears limited relation to the hours it operates. In comparison, thermal power stations must run at or near their full capacities at all times in order to achieve maximum efficiency. This makes them ill-suited to act as a supplement to wind power. An additional problem is that when winds are outside the optimal range for wind turbines (5 to 25 m/s), they cannot generate any power. If this happens during a winter cold snap, when electrical demand reaches its highest levels of the year, conventional power sources must have the capacity of meeting that entire demand. [60] [61]

In 2007, UK wind farms achieved "load factors on an unchanged configuration basis" of 27.3% for onshore and 28.3% for offshore respectively. In 2008 onshore farms achieved 29.4% and offshore farms achieved 34.9% on the same basis.[51] A study by the Renewable Energy Foundation (REF), which campaigns against the use of wind energy in the UK, claimed that only a few Scottish wind farms achieved the 28% average, while turbines in lowland England were operating at much lower levels, some at less than 10% of capacity.[62]

There is also much dispute over the necessary amount of reserve or backup required to support the large-scale use of wind energy due to the variable nature of its supply. The opponents of wind energy[who?] argue that it is necessary to have up to 80–90% backup, however National Grid which has responsibility for balancing the grid reported in June 2009 that the electricity distribution grid could cope with on-off wind energy without spending a lot on backup.[63]

[edit] See also

[edit] References

  1. ^ NewEnergyFocus wind news webpage
  2. ^ RenewableUK Wind Energy Database
  3. ^ "National Grid wind operations". http://www.nationalgrid.com/uk/Electricity/Data/WindPowerOperation/. Retrieved 2010-08-02. 
  4. ^ BWEA News – BWEA (now RenewableUK) response to John Hutton's speech
  5. ^ New Civil Engineer – Wind power: Chancellor urged to use budget to aid ailing developers
  6. ^ The Daily Telegraph (London). http://www.telegraph.co.uk/earth/main.jhtml?xml=/earth/2008/06/25/eawindfarms125.xml. 
  7. ^ a b Jha, Alok (2008-10-21). "UK overtakes Denmark as world's biggest offshore wind generator". London: guardian.co.uk. http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2008/oct/21/windpower-renewableenergy1. Retrieved 2008-11-12. 
  8. ^ a b c d Renewable UK UKWED Offshore wind farms
  9. ^ National Grid Table of Indicative Triad Demand Information showing 7 Jan 2010 peak
  10. ^ MacKay, David. Sustainable Energy - without the hot air. pp. 60–62. http://www.withouthotair.com/. Retrieved April 3, 2010. 
  11. ^ "Two Terawatts average power output: the UK offshore wind resource". http://www.claverton-energy.com/two-terawatts-average-power-output-the-uk-offshore-wind-resource.html. Retrieved 2010-08-02. 
  12. ^ RenewableUK – Offshore Wind Introduction
  13. ^ REPP report into Non-Fossil Fuel subsidies in the UK
  14. ^ McCarthy, Michael (2008-01-24). "Britain will need 12,500 wind farms to satisfy EU targets". London: The Independent. http://www.independent.co.uk/environment/climate-change/britain-will-need-12500-wind-farms-to-satisfy-eu-targets-773145.html. Retrieved 2008-10-07. 
  15. ^ RenewableUK – Round 2 map
  16. ^ The Crown Estate R1 & R2 extensions announcement
  17. ^ Map of R1 & R2 extensions
  18. ^ Round 3 developers, The Crown Estate
  19. ^ Map of Zones, The Crown Estate
  20. ^ a b Crown Estate UK Offshore Wind Report 2010
  21. ^ Scottish Offshore sites and developers, The Crown Estate
  22. ^ Map of Scottish Offshore Zones, The Crown Estate
  23. ^ SSE Project website
  24. ^ Britain's massive offshore wind power potential
  25. ^ Beatrice Wind Farm Official Website
  26. ^ RWE npower Rhyl Flats inauguration press release
  27. ^ http://www.dongenergy.com/Gunfleetsands/GunfleetSands/AboutGFS/Documents/Gunfleet_Sands_Brochure_MAY-2010_4th%20Proof.pdf
  28. ^ NewEnergyFocus article
  29. ^ SSE's Greater Gabbard Project website
  30. ^ Vattenfall Ormonde Project website
  31. ^ Scira Sheringham Shoal Project website
  32. ^ Vattenfall Thanet Project website
  33. ^ Dong Energy Walney Project website
  34. ^ RWE npower renewables Project website
  35. ^ Centrica Lincs Project website
  36. ^ "Offshore wind farms get go-ahead". BBC News. 2006-12-18. http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/kent/6188133.stm. 
  37. ^ London Array Project website
  38. ^ Crown Estate Press release for Teeside Offshore Windfarm
  39. ^ EdF Energy website
  40. ^ ScottishPower Duddon Sands Project website
  41. ^ Centrica Docking Shoal Project website
  42. ^ Warwick Energy Dudgeon Project website
  43. ^ E.ON Humber Gateway Project website
  44. ^ Centrica Race Bank Project website
  45. ^ Dong Energy Westermost Rough Project website
  46. ^ RWE npower Triton Knoll Project website
  47. ^ "Largest offshore windfarm planned". BBC News. 2007-05-16. http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/devon/6664005.stm. 
  48. ^ ScottishPower Shell Flats Project website
  49. ^ BWEA News – Decision makers must heed Stern warning on climate change
  50. ^ Energy – New and Renewable Energies – Wind Energy
  51. ^ a b Digest of United Kingdom energy statistics: 2009
  52. ^ Robinson, Sarah Firm told to repair turbine, Whitehaven News (2008-03-27) accessed 2008-03-28
  53. ^ NewEnergyFocus article
  54. ^ Fred.Olsen Projects website
  55. ^ Scottish Government Planning Applications - Muaithaebhal
  56. ^ a b Scottish Power Website
  57. ^ Scottish Government Planning Applications - Berry Burn
  58. ^ Scottish Government Planning Applications - Clyde
  59. ^ Wind power subsidy in the UK by Dr John Etherington
  60. ^ Oswald, James; Raine, Mike; Ashraf-Ball, Hezlin (June 2008). "Will British weather provide reliable electricity?". Energy Policy 36: 2312-2325. http://www.wind-watch.org/documents/wp-content/uploads/oswald-energy-policy-2008.pdf. 
  61. ^ Mason, Rowena (11 January 2010). "Wind farms produced 'practically no electricity' during Britain's cold snap". Daily Telegraph. http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/newsbysector/energy/6957501/Wind-farms-produced-practically-no-electricity-during-Britains-cold-snap.html. 
  62. ^ Clover, Charles (2006-12-09). "Wind farms 'are failing to generate the predicted amount of electricity'". The Daily Telegraph (London). http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/main.jhtml?xml=/news/2006/12/09/nwind09.xml. 
  63. ^ "UK expands wind power potential". BBC News. 2009-06-24. http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/sci/tech/8117704.stm. 

[edit] External links

Personal tools
Namespaces
Variants
Actions
Navigation
Interaction
Toolbox
Print/export
Languages