Commentary: Libya unrest brings to mind Baghdad's fall
- On the Web | More commentary from McClatchy
By Matt Schofield | The Kansas City Star
Nothing was obvious right away. The day didnt seem any deadlier than those before it.
But it was. And that scares me about whats going to happen in Libya.
It was just about eight years ago. Baghdad had fallen and really it wasnt an unhappy place. Sure, there were firefights, especially at night. But restaurants were re-opening, and the markets were getting more crowded each day. Looking at a city that seemed OK, the American decision to decrease the intensity of security made sense to everyone. We all breathed easier. For a day or so.
But soon, moving around the city with Iraqis, problems became more and more obvious. In those days I was with Sunni and Shiite, and they really couldnt have cared less about that difference. They were united in joy at the fall of their badun, Saddam. But as the city moved from conquered to occupied, they wanted their police back.
It didnt take long before the allure of outsiders pointing guns at them began to wear thin.
Their cops wouldnt be coming back. From the rules of engagement meetings I sat through, it was obvious why. The rule was: If its wearing a uniform, one in the heart, one in the head, meaning bullets. Cops were included in that. They were, after all, part of the national security force. Being a cop meant being an enemy of the United States.
A month later it became official when Paul Bremer fired the military, saying it couldnt work, couldnt regain the support of the people. Ive had heated arguments since about whether he was right or wrong. I think he was wrong, but thats me. But the arguments do tend to agree on this point: Thats really when it all fell apart and went wrong.
The Iraqi insurgency, at least at first, wasnt a conventional confrontation as much as it was a crime spree. The cops were off the streets. First unguarded military ammo dumps were emptied. After that everything else was an easy target. Banks, bankers, shops, shopkeepers. Kidnapping became so common families armed themselves for morning walks to school, kids in the middle, gun barrels pointed ahead and behind. While school was in session, which wasnt often, parents used school walls to set up defensive positions.
No one thought this would happen. Most Iraqis hated that it was happening. But in any society there are criminals. Take cops out of the equation (and even a dominating occupying army isnt in a position to play police, its simply not what they do) and that bad element runs amok. Every time I returned to Baghdad in the coming years, the Iraqis I knew and trusted talked about how crime made life more impossible each day.
With life that hard, small divisions widened. Al-Qaida exploited them well. Former friends became enemies. Neighborhoods shattered. Cities became killing zones.
Which brings us to Libya. The effort now under way may be noble but it is terrifyingly complex and fragile. Right now, fire is focused on the Libyan military, those loyal to Col. Moammar Gadhafi, ol Crazypants. Hes a badun.
But destroy that military, bring freedom and what? Whos there to mind the store? Or mind if the store is looted, the kids are kidnapped, the streets are unwalkable.
Is the rebel force moving back and forth across the desert capable of immediately establishing order in Libya? Were not seeing the signs right now. Its troubling to have no idea if they understand how to rule.
Because if they dont, right away, there wont be a police force in Libya and, well, weve seen this scene before.
Thats the problem. Wholesale slaughter is a horrible thing. But thousands who die during a couple of horrid days are no more dead than thousands who will die over years. Ive seen them drill holes in skulls in a place that into chaos. Once society breaks, it takes years to fix.
So, because I agree with President Barack Obama that this country cant afford another protracted war, I ask: If even hoping or knowing were doing good, doing the right thing we create chaos, leave behind a power vacuum that is filled by people we dont like, and taken advantage of by criminals, can we simply walk away?
We welcome comments. To post one, you must sign in using either your McClatchyDC login or your login for Facebook, Twitter or Disqus. Just click the appropriate box below.
Please keep your comment civil, short and to the point. Obscene, profane, abusive and off topic comments will be deleted. Repeat offenders will be blocked. If you find a comment abusive or inappropriate, please flag it for the moderator by placing your cursor on the comment, then clicking the "flag" link that appears. Thanks for your participation.