Reflective Mirror Spheres in Photography
by Robert Monaghan

Related Local Links:
Medium Format Home Page
Medium Format Cameras List Page
Related Links:
Mirror Vision Project

On my Weird Lenses Pages, I highlight the unique Spiratone "bird's eye view lens" which takes in 220 degrees. Now you can buy a prime Nikon fisheye lens which takes in 220 degrees too - enabling it to take in areas behind the front hemisphere of the lens (which is huge and bends backwards to get this rearward view). But the prime lens would cost as much as many budget new cars. For the price of a couple of pizzas, you can buy the Spiratone bird's eye lens (used market only).

Like its high priced competitor, the Spiratone bird's eye lens takes in 220 degrees too. But it does so thanks to a low cost reflecting metal sphere. The sphere is suspended in front of the camera lens inside a clear plastic cylinder several inches in diameter. The bottom of this plastic cylinder has a closeup or diopter lens (typically +10 diopters for a 4 inch or 100mm setup). A filter ring mount enables this tube to screw into the filter ring on your camera (possibly using an adapter from the standard size used (often 52mm)). So your camera is taking a closeup photo of the world as reflected back to it from a reflecting metal sphere. Make sense?

The edges of the sphere have a compressed but clear view of up to 220 degrees, just like the high priced nikkor. Since the metal sphere is reflecting the scene back to the camera's regular lens, the camera is inevitably in the center of every picture. So you can tell which photos were taken with the low cost adapter (camera in center of picture) versus the hopefully rented high priced Nikkor images (no camera in center of picture, but lots of photographer's toes and noses in the side imagery!).

Next time you go shopping for Christmas tree ornaments, take a close look at those thin glass spheres in the box. If you move the spheres so they are in contact, you may notice a curious optical phenomenon at the edges. The spheres darken where the reflection is being bounced back and forth between the touching spheres. Light is reflected back and forth so many times that it gets absorbed and hence darkens these edges. Nifty, huh?

If you have a close focusing macro lens, you can probably use a simple metal sphere to produce a reflected scene with enormous coverage. See our fisheye pages for related notes. Besides metal or silvered reflecting spheres, you can also use various security mirrors to get similarly distorted ultrawide coverage photographs. Getting such coverage with a prime optic might be impossible, but in any case the cost would be very high for a prime fisheye optic.

A new wrinkle on this old technique is now introduced by the computer. Using various panoramic software, the extreme distortion of such fisheye photos can be removed by the computer. The resulting image is an ultrawide, relatively undistorted image covering a tremendous field of view. Wow! For very little cost and some free software you can scan and straighten out your distorted fisheye images into passable rectilinear images (see our panoramic pages for links to free software).

The following postings provide some insight into sources for such mirrored spheres, and things you can do with them too. Our thanks to all those who have contributed these ideas and suggestions on these various public forums!


From Panoramic Mailing List:
Date: Thu, 06 Jul 2000
From: Charles Stumpfel stumpfel@arl.army.mil
Subject: light gathering vs diameter of reflecting spheres

Knowing next to nothing ---

I'd like to understand the how reflectors might be used for panoramic imaging.

A video camera was set up viewing a 3/4" diameter chrome steel ball bearing so that the ball's image filled the camera's vertical FOV.

How does the diameter of a reflecting sphere affects light gathering? In other words does a larger diameter ball bearing, imaged to still fill the FOV, cause more light to fall in the image? I'm ordering a 1" diameter ball to find out the quick way. [The 1 " diameter ball is supplied by Small Parts, Inc. in Miami FL]

Does anyone know of a supplier for precision ball bearings larger than 1" in diameter? Any specifics on other commercially available curved reflectors other than ball bearings would also be of interest.

Chas Stumpfel


From Panoramic Mailing List:
Date: Thu, 06 Jul 2000
From: Nathan Myhrvold nathanm@MICROSOFT.com
Subject: RE: light gathering vs diameter of reflecting spheres

Weather reseacher use "whole sky cameras" to record cloud cover. These are basically an ordinary camera lens pointed at a mirrored sphere - those I have seen are approx 8-12 inches in diameter. The camera appears in the picture, of course, and the view is quite distorted.

Nathan

> -----Original Message-----
> From: Charles Stumpfel [mailto:stumpfel@arl.army.mil]
> Sent: Thursday, July 06, 2000 
> To: Panorama-l@sci.monash.edu.au
> Subject: light gathering vs diameter of reflecting spheres
> 
> 
> Knowing next to nothing ---
> 
> I'd like to understand the how reflectors might be used for panoramic
> imaging.
> 
> A video camera was set up viewing a  3/4" diameter chrome steel ball
> bearing so that the ball's image filled the camera's vertical FOV.
> 
> How does the diameter of a reflecting sphere affects light 
> gathering?  In
> other words does a larger diameter ball bearing,  imaged to 
> still fill the
> FOV, cause more light to fall in the image?   I'm ordering a 
> 1" diameter
> ball to find out the quick way.  [The 1 " diameter ball is supplied by
> Small Parts, Inc. in Miami FL]
> 
> Does anyone know of a supplier for precision ball bearings 
> larger than 1"
> in diameter?   Any specifics on other commercially available curved
> reflectors other than ball bearings would also be of interest.
> 
> 
> Chas Stumpfel
> 


From Panoramic Mailing List:
Date: Thu, 06 Jul 2000
From: Helmut Dersch der@fh-furtwangen.de
Subject: Re: light gathering vs diameter of reflecting spheres

Charles Stumpfel wrote:

> I'd like to understand the how reflectors might be used for panoramic
> imaging.

Images from convex spherical mirrors can be remapped to the standard cylindrical panorama formats using my free software 'Panorama Tools'. See my website for examples of Macropanoramas using this technique.

Try also Versacorp, BeHere, and Cyclovision for commercial systems.

 
> How does the diameter of a reflecting sphere affects light gathering? 
> 
> Does anyone know of a supplier for precision ball bearings larger than 1"
> in diameter?  

Ball bearings don't have optical grade sufaces. Much better results can be obtained by using 'real' spherical mirrors. These are manufactured using glas lenses, which are coated with aluminum. Most lens manufacturers sell almost any size and shape, eg Newport and Spindler&Hoyer;, where I got mine from.

Helmut Dersch

-------------------------------------
Spherical Panoramas, Macro Panoramas, Free Panorama Software,
Mailing List "Immersive Imaging": http://www.fh-furtwangen.de/~dersch


From Panoramic Mailing List;
Date: Thu, 06 Jul 2000
From: MIKE GRACE amazing50@hotmail.com
Subject: RE: light gathering vs diameter of reflecting spheres

Does anyone know of a supplier for precision ball bearings larger than 1" in diameter? Any specifics on other commercially available curved reflectors other than ball bearings would also be of interest.

Chas Stumpfel

Safety supply companies sell all sorts of curved reflectors made of plastic. They are used in factories to improve visibility and are quite good optically.

Mike Grace
amazing50@bigfoot.com
http://www.geocities.com/Paris/LeftBank/3923 /


From Panoramic Mailing List:
Date: Thu, 06 Jul 2000
From: Alan Zinn azinn@netbox.com
Subject: Re: light gathering vs diameter of reflecting spheres

you wrote:

>Knowing next to nothing ---
>
>I'd like to understand the how reflectors might be used for panoramic
>imaging.
>
>A video camera was set up viewing a  3/4" diameter chrome steel ball
>bearing so that the ball's image filled the camera's vertical FOV.
>
>How does the diameter of a reflecting sphere affects light gathering?  In
>other words does a larger diameter ball bearing,  imaged to still fill the
>FOV, cause more light to fall in the image?   I'm ordering a 1" diameter
>ball to find out the quick way.  [The 1 " diameter ball is supplied by
>Small Parts, Inc. in Miami FL]
>
>Does anyone know of a supplier for precision ball bearings larger than 1"
>in diameter?   Any specifics on other commercially available curved
>reflectors other than ball bearings would also be of interest.
>
>
>Chas Stumpfel
>

Chas,

Maybe a dumb question but why not xmas balls? Also there are vacuum plated "chrome" spheres at craft stores. I have some I used for a photo project (not pans).

AZ

New Minneapols pans 6/30/00
Lookaround Panoramic Camera and Gallery:
http://www.geocities.com/SoHo/Gallery/8874/


From Panoramic Mailing List:
Date: Fri, 07 Jul 2000
From: Charles Stumpfel stumpfel@arl.army.mil
Subject: Re: light gathering vs diameter of reflecting spheres

My original message (bottom) on the acrylic hemispheres with 9" dia. at $30-40 was from memory and likely wrong since I could not find it again. Badger has 9" dia stainless hemispheres but no price was listed. They also have larger diameter acrylic hemispheres.

Sun-Rise has some prices on larger spheres but they are more than the $30-40.

Chas Stumpfel

This company supplies hemispherical mirrors for safety applications:

Badger Merchandise Service

1-800-771-4972

(phone message says they are closed until Monday)

http://www.badgermart.com/sentinel.html

----------------------------------------------------------------------------

Another company was

http://www.sun-rise.com/mirrors/621884.001.html

----------------------------------------------------------------------------

Probably found by searching convex mirror.......safety mirror......whole sky mirror.... all sky mirror.

Sun-Rise states these acrylic hemispherical mirrors are coated on the inner side - not front surface. I think they are sold mostly for viewing with the eye.

For some applications there might be objectionable reflections, especially of strong sources, from the uncoated acrylic surface. ??

Chas Stumpfel


From Panoramic Mailing List:
Date: Fri, 07 Jul 2000
From: Alan Zinn azinn@netbox.com
Subject: Re: light gathering vs diameter of reflecting spheres

you wrote:

>Spiratone made a 220 degree bird's eye lens for circa $20 US; it used a 
>lens thread mount, clear plastic tube to hold an aluminized spheroidal 
>surface, and a closeup diopter lens to bring it into focus. Folks 
>suggested you could do the same thing with a +10 diopter lens, a silver 
>xmas tree bulb (epoxied inside for strength?), and a clear PVC tube and 
>broken out filter epoxied to the inside of the PVC tube. 
>
>see http://www.tbk.de/news/birdeye1.htm for somewhat similar newer item
>and http://www.smu.edu/~rmonagha/third/weird.html Wierd Lenses pages
>and ~rmonagha/bronfe.html fisheye pages on related low cost options...
>
>regards bobm

Don't know if this will help but I was just in a Michaels craft store and saw a 12in. mirrored glass "Gazing sphere" for $24.00 US. It is for making lawn ornaments. It looked very nice. I wouldn't think too fancy a sphere would be necessary for VDT display. I presume the camera is edited out.

AZ

New Minneapols pans 6/30/00
Lookaround Panoramic Camera and Gallery:
http://www.geocities.com/SoHo/Gallery/8874/


Email suggestions, updates, comments, links, and glitches to fix - Thanks!

Medium Format Home Page


Site Accesses since 9/10/97
Medium Format Site Startup Date: Feb. 14, 1998