The Science Fiction of Cordwainer Smith, by Karen
Hellekson
The Science Fiction of Cordwainer
Smith, by Karen L. Hellekson, is the only book I know
of that is devoted entirely to this topic.
Here's what the publisher, Mcfarland and Company, says about
it:
This critical work
concentrates on the science fiction writings of Paul
Linebarger, who wrote under the pseudonym Cordwainer
Smith, as well as other pseudonyms he created to reflect
his different writing styles. His writings give voice to
concerns about humanity and personal struggle; his ideas
about love, loss, alienation, and psychic pain continue
to resonate today.
This work begins with a
brief biographical sketch of Cordwainer Smith, linking
elements of his past to his writing and focusing on his
contributions to science fiction as well as his concern
with humanity. Also discussed are Smith's published and
unpublished novel- length non-science fiction, his
revision process, the true man-underpeople dichotomy in
his published and unpublished short fiction, and his
only published novel-length science fiction work
Norstrilia.
I've read much of it. As I have often said, I'm not as
much a CS fan as someone who grew up surrounded by his mind --
so I am not really the best person to review it. I think that
anyone who is fascinated by CS's writings and enjoys literary
analysis might like to read it. It's fun to see discussion of
so many CS-related themes in one place.
Here's a quote, to give you a taste:
"The Great Pain of Space is a recurring theme in Smith's
science fiction, and one that merits investigation. In
Smith's earlier science fiction stories, the Great Pain of
Space is literal; people literally experience horrible pain
and death simply from attempting to traverse space. In
Smith's later works, the pain is sublimated and
metaphorical. In 'Think Blue, Count Two,' something inside
people is triggered by space that causes insanity, despair,
and pain. Regardless of how this pain is articulated,
however, it is connected with space and humanity's attempt
to travel through it. I certainly agree that Smith, in his
science fiction, was working through his own psychological
problems."[Page 88]
The paperback book is 158 pages long: that's 104 pages of
the text itself, followed by a glossary of CS terms, a
bibliography, a list of manuscripts at the Spencer Research
Library in Lawrence, Kansas, and an index. Its $35 price tag
seems steep to me, but I suppose academic books tend to cost
more than general interest ones, due to the smaller
readerships. As a librarian myself, I can't help reminding you
that your public or academic library may be able to get it for
you on interlibrary loan. And there's a good chance you can get
a used copy online; I have links at the bottom of this
page.
Andy Sawyer, Science Fiction Librarian at the University of
Liverpool, and Reviews Editor of Foundation: The
International Review of Science Fiction kindly sent me
some comments that were to appear in Foundation
84. See The Science Fiction Foundation Collection webpage:
http://www.liv.ac.uk/~asawyer/sffchome.html
Andy's comments on The Science Fiction of Cordwainer
Smith
It draws together a body of existing research, and is
especially interesting on the early "mainstream" fiction,
which few fans have read. She quotes, for instance, an
interesting quotation from Ria (1947) about "the
fluent deep roar of a resounding brass instrument of some
kind . . . something which sounded like the instrumentality
of man". She identifies various themes of loss, love and
alienation in his work. Although her analysis can be
superficial at times (she rightly stresses the way he deals
with the question of "what makes us human?" but the final
"afterword" summarises Smith's work with at least seven
uses of the phrase "the human condition" in four pages,
which is probably six too many) she has produced an
enjoyable book on a fine writer.
Although her glossary is useful, no serious scholar or
fan of Smith should be without Anthony R. Lewis's
Concordance,
now in its third edition. It's only necessary to compare
entries such as the one for "Judson, E. Z. C." in both.
Hellekson's is fine as far as the reference within Smith's
work goes, but it is Lewis who tells us that the "Ancient
American poet, 1823-1866" was the writer of over 400 books,
many as "Ned Buntline" who was Buffalo Bill Cody's
promoter. (Although it is Hellekson who has an entry for
Norstrilia's "Absent Queen" without, however, explaining
the reference as - at least so I have always taken it - an
echo of Australian identification with a British
"homeland".)
You can likely find the book at Alibris.
Here are links to Amazon and eBay.com as well.
|